Over at College Football News, they’re doing that Experts Roundtable thing they did last year. Along with their own Pete Fiutak and Richard Cirminello, here’s the list of guys they’ve got reviewing the world of college football as we know it:
- Charles Davis, NFL Network/FOX Sports
- Dennis Dodd, CBSSports.com – College Football Columnist
- Bruce Feldman, ESPN.com – College Football Columnist
- Steve Greenberg, The Sporting News – College Football Columnist
- Teddy “Mr. Media” Greenstein, Chicago Tribune – College Football Columnist, Media Columnist
- Stewart Mandel, SI.com – College Football Columnist
The discussion slate has been considerably expanded this go ’round, as they’re shooting the breeze on fifteen or so different topics. Here’s a taste of a few of their comments:
From What aspect of college football should you care about, but really don’t?
Stewart Mandel: I know it sounds bad to say this, but the scandals. I know as a journalist I should be outraged and ready to tear down walls every time any hint of unseemliness arises at a school — be it player arrests, academic scandals, etc. — but I’m just so jaded to it at this point that I pretty much shrug my shoulders.
From Should a two loss LSU team really have won the national title?
Dennis Dodd: Absolutely. Here’s the problem: Once you lose one game in this system, it’s a crapshoot. If you lose two, you’ve got absolutely no argument for being in the national championship game. But last season was the 500-year flood of college football — seven teams with two losses in the top 10 of the BCS in the first week of December.
Someone had to get in. That it was LSU didn’t bother me. In the end, The Tigers benefitted from winning the strongest league in the country. What’s wrong with that?
It was all the outrage that followed that got to me. Why? To me, USC was eliminated because it was the victim of the biggest upset in the game’s history — losing at home at Stanford. I suppose Georgia had a beef but I really got turned off with the whole Michael Adams, Rose Bowl argument. By the end of the day, Georgia looked like donkeys because its actions were a backhanded slap at the Sugar Bowl.
Missouri lost twice to Oklahoma. West Virginia lost to Pittsburgh. LSU was basically the last comic standing when it came time to pick two teams to play for the national championship.
From How should college football be more like the NFL?
Bruce Feldman: I love the NFL playoffs format and the college doesn’t have that. On the opposite side, college football has no such things as games that don’t count in some preseason. I know GMs and NFL execs would argue it helps them decide who should be on their roster and make sound business decisions, but make your cuts off scrimmages and practice.
From Your college football guilty pleasure
Teddy Greenstein: I like when Charlie Weis is interviewed at halftime on NBC with his Irish trailing by four touchdowns.
Definitely a mixed bag…