My season’s end Mumme Poll ballot

Here we go.

  • Alabama*
  • Arkansas
  • Boise State
  • LSU
  • Michigan
  • Oklahoma State
  • Oregon
  • Southern Cal
  • Stanford
  • Wisconsin

COMMENTS

  • Weirdly enough, the only change I could bring myself to make after bowl season was to give Alabama the tiebreaker.
  • Tough call for the last spot between Wisconsin and South Carolina, but I just think the Badgers would win that head-to-head match up.
  • It’s amazing to see how much the computers like three-loss Oklahoma.
  • I wonder how different everyone’s final rankings would look if Boise State had made that field goal in the TCU game.
  • Also getting consideration:  Michigan State and TCU.
About these ads

13 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football

13 responses to “My season’s end Mumme Poll ballot

  1. Bob

    Arkansas #2? Seriously? Over the team that beat them by 40 and lost only 1?

    • My list is in alphabetical order. The MP ballot doesn’t rank teams, remember?

      • Bob

        Got it. My bad.

      • Cojones

        Then why have I been explaining why I ranked them in order? Duh. Also thought the overall rankings came from their order as well as how often a team was listed. Duh. Why aren’t there ties for the top five at least?
        Haven’t participated for 3 weeks. No new info was coming up to change the top 10.

  2. Nate Dawg

    Senator, had to go Mich St over Mich cuz of the head to head and I was impressed, overall, with their defense in the bowl game. It was better or as good as advertised I thought – and really good at stuffing the run up the middle (ha! see what I did there?).
    Also I gave LSU the nodd over bammer. I think 13-1 is better than 12-1…I think.

    • AusDawg85

      LSU = SECCG + 13 wins.

      Bama = 1 and 1 vs. LSU

      LSU > Bama

      Or does the regular season not count?! ;-)

      • Nate Dawg

        Confirmation confirmed. Thanks!

      • AthensHomerDawg

        It does …unless—> the team you beat by three points in triple overtime during the regular season ends up ranked number two and eligible to play the number one team. Again. Also if said team doesn’t allow you to cross the 50 yard line until the fourth quarter and holds you scoreless. Then and only then is the regular season game disregarded. ;-)

        • Mayor of Dawgtown

          They need to just keep playing games until one team wins 2 in a row.

        • AusDawg85

          Well then they should have both played OSU and Stanford. Then the winners could play… Oregon? No, LSU beat them already. So did Stanford, but The Cardinal (WTF is THAT anyway???!) lost too.

          Wait…doesn’t a playoff fix this?

    • Cojones

      Good respect for a worthy opponent, Nate.

  3. Macallanlover

    Your point about Boise’s missed FG shows how tenuous the line between perceived success and shortfall is drawn. You can say the same about our missed FG, or Stanford, or Bama on November 5, or dozens of others where a kicker made, or missed, a FG during the season. It is why the determination of the “best” team will always be arguable….playoff or not.

  4. Someone left Bama off their ballot entirely. And it wasn’t me. And I hate Bama.