I questioned the “little guys are getting it stuck to them again” criticism of the APR at the time the last report came out, but felt that there were some valid issues raised about implementation of the policy.
… That’s not to say that there aren’t abuses of the system. Hall is right when he criticizes the ease with which waivers are granted to certain programs. To an extent, Tomey’s argument that his program got screwed for honoring the lax academic standards of his predecessor isn’t without some merit. But it’s hard to say that’s a valid defense. It’s just that other schools shouldn’t be allowed to get away with what is most likely similar past bad behavior.
Now comes USA Today with some further evidence that sanctions aren’t being evenly distributed between the BCS conferences and the mid-majors. For example,
… The Pac-10, for example, saw only three of 14 subpar teams sanctioned (21%) while the neighboring Western Athletic saw 23 of 34 (68%) and the Mountain West 10 of 15 (67%).
The SEC saw only five of 20 low-APR teams sanctioned (25%). The Sun Belt, with roughly the same geographic footprint, saw 16 of 46 (35%).
Now stats are fine in the abstract, but it would be useful to know more about the specifics. As the article notes,
… The bigger-budget schools are more capable of beefing up academic support programs and taking other supportive measures such as covering summer school costs for incoming athletes and reducing missed class time by flying rather than busing to games.
And that may very well be the case in many circumstances. Remember that Dick Tomey admitted his school didn’t even have an academic support program in place until three years ago. But you wonder if there’s something else going on here. Unfortunately, the article doesn’t give us any indication if that’s the case. It would certainly make for an interesting follow up.
In the meantime, scratch your head over a factoid like this…
Both opponents in last season’s Motor City Bowl, Purdue and Central Michigan, posted football APRs beneath the NCAA’s 925 cutoff. Purdue had a 920 but wasn’t penalized. Central had a 922 and lost two scholarships…
and wonder if the players are benefiting from the new academic order. Which, after all, is the whole point to the exercise.
***************************************************************
UPDATE: As usual, Sunday Morning Quarterback adds some cogent thoughts on this topic here.
You must be logged in to post a comment.