The verdict is in and the pundits have spoken: Ryan Mallett is the real deal. Joe Cox, on the other hand… well, did you hear how terrible Arkansas’ defense is?
Here’s Mandel’s take:
The early scouting report on Arkansas: QB Ryan Mallett is as good as advertised (he threw for 408 yards and five touchdowns against Georgia to remain the nation’s pass-efficiency leader), but Bobby Petrino‘s defense is horr-i-ble. With his various ailments behind him, Dawgs QB Joe Cox spent the bulk of the night lofting passes down field to wide-open receivers (resulting in five TDs) in a 52-41 win.
At least he mentioned Cox in passing, which is more than Rivals’ Olin Buchanan did.
Arkansas needs a defense. QB Ryan Mallett makes Arkansas dangerous, but the Razorbacks won’t be a factor in the SEC West race unless their defense makes dramatic improvement quickly. Mallett arrived in Fayetteville with the reputation as a strong-armed passer. He demonstrated that against Georgia by passing for 408 yards and five touchdowns. Three of his scoring tosses covered at least 30 yards. But Mallett’s brilliance wasn’t nearly enough to compensate for Arkansas’ porous defense, which allowed 530 yards in a 52-41 loss. Mallett’s passing will ensure the Razorbacks will post some wins. But the defense doesn’t figure to be good enough for the Razorbacks to be serious challengers in the division.
Pretty strange, hunh? Two straight weeks opposing quarterbacks torch Georgia’s defense, get tons of attention (and credit) for doing so and Cox, who outperformed each, is little more than an afterthought. (In the credit where credit is due department, Cox does get a pat on the back from CFN’s Richard Cirminiello.)
On the other hand, this quote from Joe’s head coach during the week before the Arkansas game turned out to be eerily prescient:
… The subject of deep balls came up when Richt was talking about Cox’s arm strength on his Monday radio show.
“He can throw the ball far enough to throw just about anything we want,” Richt said. “We’re not going to throw it 65 yards or 75 yards, but there aren’t many Matthew Staffords in the world. I’ll say this–when we do throw the ball deep, I’ll bet you we complete more deep balls this year than we completed last year. Mostly because Joe will put it in play and give a great player like A.J. Green a chance to make the play. If we overthrow him, we get nothing. If we throw it on the money, it’s awesome and if we throw it short, A.J. can either get the ball or usually the defender interferes like happened in the ballgame there.”
Whatever else, the Hogs can’t say they weren’t warned.
**********************************************************************
UPDATE: For yuks, take a look at Joe Cox’ projected stats for 2009. Tell me you wouldn’t have taken those before the season in a heartbeat.