Even Condi Rice is an upgrade over this.
Filed under BCS/Playoffs
Didn’t have to click the link to know this is something about the damn computer ratings.
And in the “coach’s” poll, someone put FSU…12th, and Baylor…22nd. So there’s that.
I have always thought that the computer ratings were suspect because no one but the originator knew what the hell was going on with them. That being said I still think the “Committee” for the selection of the final four should just be charged with creating the parameters for a rating computer program that would be transparent. Everyone would know what the rankings were based on and there would be no human bias. The old Smoke Filled Room is not the way I want the final four picked.
We can change the way we choose who plays for the MNC in mid-season, but not tweak a horribly written penalty that may have knocked a team out of contention?
Who authorized changing the formula in the first place?
Apparently Jeff Sagarin wags this most shaggy dog and calls his own shots, incredibly.
Its ridiculous that he is given such an important role yet his formula is secret and we have no way of knowing if its even fair. He could be picking names out of a hat.
Assigning a number with a few decimals makes it official.
Nothing matters until the end of the season. Then select.
How many games have the Dawgs lost in a row under CMR?
Dawgs out of top 25 and the BCS.
Hard to get ranked when you drop a game to Vandy.
Will GTP post a list of the injured players by position and the game they went out in. Also include those before the season.
Since when did I become your research assistant, Will?
And what does this have to do with the BCS in the first place?
Why would you even respond Seantor?? Pigs, mud and all.
Bring me a soda, BITCH!
The computer ranking as constituted are basically a human poll of 6 voters. I am not sure what the difference between handing a ballot off to an SID or handing one off to an algorithm would be if no one can verify the methodology or even the result of the algorithm. I am not against numerical analysis – I enjoy Connelly’s blog on that front, and he’s helped me understand a lot about the game I missed before I started reading his work.
Condi is expected to lead the enhanced interrogation subcommittee to nail down the Pure Elo info that Jeff has at his fingertips. Most predict that this crystal blue persuasion exercise will not be a good experience for him.
Well at least Jeff got it fixed. This week he has Northern Illinois at #3, where, as any college football fan knows, they obviously belong.
Condi can’t decide if it’s Bama Oregon or Bama FS. Hey. She’s a lady, not a poll.
Senator I must take an anonymous stand here, kind of like that crazy man that used to preach on that public soap box next to Tate. You allow a lot of dissension, have you ever kicked anyone off?
Not for expressing an opinion. But I’ve kicked a few off for behavior issues.
I agree. The “computers” are a farce. It’s like something from the early 60s where if IBM and the RAND Corporation put some numbers down we were all supposed to nod soberly and accept our beating. Except at least RAND wanted to retain enough credibility to be able to fool us the next time. These shysters are ostentatiously making it up as they go along.
Condi and The Old (Mostly) White Guys are an upgrade, but they need to go the full basketball and develop an RPI-like metric that (a) makes sense to most intelligent outsiders and (b) everyone on the committee agrees to take seriously. Not slavishly follow, take seriously. So sure, take a team with a lower Pigskin RPI, but be prepared to be called on it and have an explanation for why.
That’s change we can believe in, to coin a phrase.
“The SEC championship, that’s a milestone for the team,” (Aaron) Davis said. “That’s one of the goals we set before the season started. … Guys want this game bad.”– AB-H, 12/1/17
Subscribe in a reader