At the risk of inviting the wrath of trolls on my head, I thought I’d take a moment to parse some of the tea leaves from yesterday’s scrimmage. Obviously, the big story is what’s happening with the quarterback battle. If we all hoped going into the spring that there would be competition for the starting spot, as opposed to Ramsey falling into it (which is what Mason assumed would have been the case had Bobo stayed as offensive coordinator), that’s still alive. But it’s not Jacob Park who’s providing the heat.
Georgia’s quarterback competition is now a two-man race, and it’s tight at the top.
The Bulldogs won’t come out and say that, but their actions during spring practice make it clear that the starting job next season will be decided between Brice Ramsey and Faton Bauta. Through the first two scrimmages, those two quarterbacks are getting virtually all of the snaps — and all the pass attempts — with the first and second offenses.
Meanwhile, Jacob Park’s participation has been almost exclusively with the third team, with some limited repetitions coming on the second unit.
In fact, when coach Mark Richt was reading off statistics from Saturday’s scrimmage, the second of the spring, he initially forgot to include Park’s all together.
Richt claims none of the three have been eliminated from consideration, though. Yesterday marked the second straight scrimmage that Park had fewer opportunities to throw the ball than did the other two. Richt chalks some of that up to rotation, but even he admits that term doesn’t mean the same thing now that it did a week ago.
“The first scrimmage was just how we had the roll — every day, a different guy had the one unit, a different guy had the two and three. So it just happened to be on that day, that was the day that Brice was one, Faton was two, and Park was three,” Richt said. “But this time around we wanted to make sure Park got reps with the twos instead of the three unit. We did rotate the other guys more. It wasn’t like the whole day Brice or the whole day Faton with the ones. We wanted to keep rotating that around and we’re not done rotating. We’re still learning.”
Had I to guess – and it’s not like I have anything better to do, right? – I’d say that Park has two things working against him right now. One, he’s simply less experienced than the competition. Two, you have to wonder if he’s shaken off those bad habits he admitted picking up when running the scout team last season. And judging from this,
“You know what, they’re getting there. They really are,” Richt said. “They’re learning a lot. Of course, the better you protect, the easier it is to prove that you know your progressions and can get to your second and third guy. We had a few more catches for our running backs, which means we hit more check downs than we have. We’d been trying to always make the big-league throw down the middle. … We had only pick collectively and we had a lot more in the first scrimmage.”
it’s pretty clear that the head man is putting the same emphasis on not taking risks on offense that he did last season, an approach that seems as valid this year as it was in 2014, given Georgia’s strengths on offense.
That’s not to say we should stick a fork in Park’s chances just yet. There’s still the rest of the spring and August practice to go through, and maybe even some time in the opening two games, if the coaches really are taking their time to reach a final decision. But that “We’re still learning” comment cuts both ways.
On to Bauta, though. The kid whose chances most of us thought were dead after Ramsay passed him in the pecking order last season has resurrected them. Has the change at offensive coordinator given him a new lease on life? Maybe. But it sounds like maybe he deserves a little credit for some basic tenacity.
Bauta was always known as the most mobile quarterback on Georgia’s roster. But his passing and command of the offense have improved.
“From the day Faton has been here, I’ve always thought Faton really was one of the hardest workers I’ve ever seen on any level of any sport I’ve ever played,” tight end Jay Rome said. “I mean, Faton works hard, year-round, and I think it’s really paying off for him. I think the biggest thing is he’s just gaining more confidence in himself and in his arm.
“Some people might look at Faton as just a running guy in years past. But I think people are really underestimating how good of a pass-thrower that Faton is and how much of a pass-thrower that he’s become.”
What makes him a better passer?
“I really feel it’s his ability to find the open guy and really let it loose,” Rome said. “Not to be too flustered about somebody coming in. He’s stepping up in the pocket, he’s not looking to run first. He’s really finding the open guy, and he’s putting lasers on people.”
I doubt he suddenly has Ramsey’s arm strength, but after last season, is that really necessary for Georgia to be successful on offense? Is avoiding mistakes more important to Richt and Schottenheimer than having a quarterback who can make all the throws Murray and Stafford could make? I don’t know, but Richt sure sounded happy about checkdowns.
“Last week, he threw more balls that could have been picked, in my opinion,” Richt said, adding later, “As the scrimmage was going on, I didn’t see a lot of bad decisions by the quarterbacks.”
And on a team with Nick Chubb and other talented running backs, simply making good decisions might be the most important barometer.
“We’ve been forcing the ball, trying to make the big-league throw down the middle, or the deeper (pass),” Richt said. “Sometimes your first progression is deep and you work your way short. And sometimes there’s a protection issue where you’ve got to cut the ball loose. This whole last week, we worked a lot harder on (making) sure you know who your check-downs are and be willing to take it.”
Of course, what you’d really like is a combination of great arm strength and sound decision-making. And a pony, I guess. But you go to war with the quarterbacks you have, and it sounds like Richt will take being careful over arm cannons. Which I assume means Bauta’s chances aren’t an illusion. Should make for an interesting G-Day.
Enough on the quarterbacks. Another point of interest is something that was suggested by Schottenheimer’s pro tendencies to involve the tight end in his offenses. We’re starting to see something in the spring along those lines.
One trend that seems to have emerged in spring camp is that the Bulldogs will continue to target tight ends with regularity. Jay Rome, Jeb Blazevich and early-enrollee Jackson Harris each had three catches, and Harris caught two for touchdowns during Saturday’s scrimmage. Rome and Blazevich had seven receptions between them in the first scrimmage.
“I definitely feel like we had a really good day (Saturday), and we had a good day last Saturday as well,” Rome said. “The system that (offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer) brought here to Georgia is really tight-end friendly. If we keep getting opportunities we’re going to keep making plays.”
That’s the first time I’ve seen someone refer to Schottenheimer bringing in his system. And, again, given the relative strengths and weaknesses of Georgia’s offense at this point, more use of the tight ends makes good sense.
On defense, it’s not about installing a new system, or even figuring out the key player to run it. It’s more about figuring how to fit the existing pieces in the puzzle. One good thing to note is that it seems the coaches made good decisions about talent evaluation, as both Amaechi and Ganus continue to shine. Richt singled both out for praise in terms of being quick learners.
Finally, if you’re interested, here’s the latest configuration of the starting secondary:
… Sophomore Reggie Wilkerson is working with the No. 1 defense as the “star,” or nickel back. The rest of the starting secondary has Quincy Mauger at strong safety, Dominick Sanders at free safety and Aaron Davis and Malkom Parrish at the corners.
This is Jeremy Pruitt we’re talking about here, so don’t exactly consider that etched in stone. More like drawn in sand on a beach somewhere…
My concern about Bauta hasn’t been that his arm was weak but that he wasn’t accurate or confident with it. Given the different skill sets and the similarity of performance (statistically anyway) I would be content with a 1a and 1b platoon system. Having both game ready and being able to go with the “hot hand” could be very advantageous. It makes each defense prepare for both. Any injury is less impactful.
LikeLike
The trolls may have broken your blog, Senator. In the comments section, I’m seeing Derek’s comment run over into the right sidebar, making it partially illegible. I’m on a Chrome browser, if that matters. I’ll see in a moment whether my comment runs out into the “GATA” dog-biting picture at right after I post this. I’ll try to look at it on Firefox, too.
LikeLike
Yep. And when you try to post a new post, and not a reply to a previous post, the “Post Comment” button is hidden/not there. Just letting you know. Hate to bother you with it on Easter.
LikeLike
It’s not the trolls, it’s something hinky with WP. My apologies.
LikeLike
Trolls on Easter? WTH? Release your inner Gandalf, Bluto!
LikeLike
Go dawgs sickem woof woof! 🐶🐶🐶
LikeLike
So, realistically, how does Bauta’s arm strength compare? I’m assuming it’s weaker than Ramsey’s, but where would it fall compared to Murray or Mason?
LikeLike
Closer to Mason than Murray, at least based on what I saw last season.
Ask me again after next Saturday.
LikeLike
I would respectfully disagree with that. From what I saw last year there was Mason in one class and not a lot of difference in the other three with Ramsey holding a slight lead in just sheer strength and Bauta hold a lead in knowledge.
LikeLike
He asked me about arm strength… you disagree, but say Ramsey holds a lead in arm strength.
Color me confused.
LikeLike
Because I’m saying it’s a small lead and that Bauta’s arm strength is closer to Ramsey’s than Mason’s.
LikeLike
AM freshman/sophomore arm strength for FB.
LikeLike
I’m not sure what you are saying here.
LikeLike
Saying Bauta’s arm strength is close to what Murray had freshman and sophomore year. It appeared to me that Murray’s arm strength increased – especially his senior year. There were several articles about him working on his mechanics and using his legs more to get more zip. I thought he had better arm strength late in his career than early on.
IMO Ramsey, Bauta, and Mason were in three completely different categories as to arm strength with Ramsey the strongest by far and Mason the weakest by far. Bauta was in the middle and not really close to Ramsey or Mason. Btw, from seeing them throw in person, Ramsey’s arm appeared a lot stronger than Murray’s too.
LikeLike
I would agree that Ramsey’s is stronger (I wouldn’t say a lot) than Murray”s. I would put Murray’s and Bauta’s as about even. But I would put both of them closer to Ramsey than Mason.
LikeLike
Can’t disagree there, Murray and Bauta may be closer to Ramsey than they are to Mason.
LikeLike
What stands out to me is the depth. Seems like healthy competition at most positions. And the newbees will be coming in a few months to fill up the roster. Glad to see the guys coming back from injuries getting reps – Turman, JSW, Rome, etc.
LikeLike
Nice report with a lot to think about. I can’t wait till after the game
when the trolls will enlighten us all to who’s the starter and where
the coaches have it all wrong.
LikeLike
(JUst shorten the lines on your reply and it won’t be hidden in the ad margin.)
LikeLike
WCD brings up something new to us here in Dawg Nation; depth. Not sure we can digest that in the midst of looking for heros, but it’s very important to us when considering how far this team can go. Positions being replaced by equal athletes when someone goes down keeps opponent’s Ds and Os from preying on a perceived weakness. Let’em go after the second and third rotation guys; who cares? Opponents may be in for a few big surprises when they find these guys are as competent as first stringers. One thing it gives to us is a feeling of impunity concerning suspensions or injury; whereas, it affected our psyche negatively in the past plus gave some opponent teams confidence to exploit what they saw as a temporary weakness. Depth nips that pome ‘d rue in the bud.
It’s good to see the TEs involved more, especially since we saw such terrific play from Rome in a bowl game a couple of years ago. Been waitin’ for his big comeout party and maybe this is his year for a good shot. Someone mentioned the other day how great it looked for those TEs rambling down the field dragging the D with them. Since they are becoming targets to fear, we may see a wholesale affect on the WR group (and downfield blocking by those guys as well) that suddenly makes the TE/WR group a big offensive weapon combined with a dynamite running game.
With Turman, Douglas and other runners getting holes, we also don’t have to rely so heavily on the big three RBs and attention has to be made to those guys when in the game. Any D has to make big decisions against that group on every play when you don’t know whether they are going to run the ball or blast you with a block that will blow a hole big enough to drive a truck through and free the next guy who has the ball. Love it, love it, love it.
LikeLike
I would feel better if Sony and Marshall could stay healthy. Very optimistic about the D. Maybe we will be able to overcome turnovers and not have to score 40 to win
LikeLike
I’ve been saying the bowl game was a preview of the new normal. We had much less passing game (QB out, then Bennett), didn’t score as much, but the defense stepped up and did its job. Now, no one will confuse that Louisville team with a great offense, but the fact is, under Grantham, everybody’s offense scored a bunch on us. We just have to be stronger up the middle, where our weakness may be this year. But I look for a very competent defense overall, and the O won’t have to score every time it touches the ball.
LikeLike
A lot of questions running through my head at this point but there seems to be positive answers among the choices. I don’t know that I ever recall as many “ready for primetime players” in the mix going into a season, and that doesn’t include the incoming talent, nor the guys not participating due to injury.
The mixed emotions I have are: 1) the number of sacks allowed (10) means the defense must be hellacious on rushing the passer against a pretty good OL, but the QBs only threw one pick in over 60 attempts, 2) the OL must be good at run blocking, or the DL and backers are still weak against the run because we had about 260 yards rushing without the three best RBs in the scrimmage, and 3) the QB talent is separating themselves and there are two candidates pleasing the coach about their improvement on check downs and decision making but one guy seems to be slipping away faster than expected. The number of plays certainly impacts the passing and rushing yardage, maybe by 35% given the 120 snaps. Wasn’t crazy about Morgan being 3-6 on FGs, but I don’t know the distance they were from, or the wind situation (there was also a missed XPT).
Of course we also don’t know what matchups were involved with the sacks, rushing yardage, pass success, etc. Even Richt and his staff cannot understand what they saw; we need “Ed The All Knowing” to tell us what he saw from the comfort of his couch, unobstructed by football knowledge, or being within sight, or hearing distance of the action..
LikeLike
Cojones, the unknowing , says that the mix of 1st, 2nd and 3rd plus subs are too mixed up on O and D to tell a whole helluva lot. I just looked at the positives with the idea of being thankful they didn’t trip over their dicks. Not too much else we can get from it, Mac.
There may be something to the Parks indicator of being less and Bauta being more. Depends upon which scrimmage and the players being complimentary of their favorite when they are descriptive of each’s athleticism. Anytway, Richt will certainly have the correct ideas for what he wants leading this buncha fun-lovin’ yahoos this year. We will see when we see, but don’t think we will until Fall. Everyone of us commentin’ is too itchy for painting a mental picture of this team before it happens. Fans be that way.
LikeLike
Ed is … (gone). That’s it. We are all guests here. Go Dawgs. Let’s roll!.. and remember, let’s appreciate what we got here.
…oh and Happy Holidays.
LikeLike
I somehow missed the AJ Turman deal. Is he really a viable option at RB? What’s this all about.. Somebody give me the skinny.
LikeLike
Allow me. AJ a 4 star recruit in 2013 has the measurables at 6′ 212lbs. He got hurt early so others filled in behind Gurley and while recovering (and I think got hurt again) we recruited Sony and Chubb in 2014…both of who saw early playing time. AJ just fell behind in reps. Its tough competing at this level…even harder to come from behind. I welcome any corrections by those who are more informed but I would call this the ‘skinny’.
LikeLike
He was hurt all of last season, but he seems to have some talent, from what former players have said (and from whatever you can take from scrimmage stats). I think most would like to see a bigger sample size of what he can do, but at the very least, he gives us another scholarship body on the RB depth chart, which can thin out quickly.
LikeLike
Muchas gracias amigos. Sorry, I work a lot in Mexico.
I sure hope the kid is good and can contribute in a flamboyant way.
Cheers
LikeLike
JSW and MM healthy (a big if) and Bauta playing QB, and using the tight ends could be a very difficult offense to stop. There’s a lot of speed on the outside. The quarterback can run, the tight ends can threaten the middle of the field. Which is all before the best running back in college football touches the ball. That’s very interesting.
Just for simplicity assume Bauta and Ramsey are roughly equal throwing interceptions. I wonder which is better – Ramsey being able to go downfield a bit better or Bauta making a defense account for the QB running?
Should be fun.
LikeLike
Yes, a lot of crayons in CBS’ box…and a lot of stress on opposing DCs. Good point about Bauta’s edge in a close competition. Add to this a much improved defense that shouldn’t require the offensive firepower we have had the past few seasons. Not being over confident at all but there is much to be upbeat about as we approach the start of fall.
LikeLike
Mac, I know it is out of fashion to worry about the kicking game, but with an erratic field goal kicker so far and a punter with a disc bulge, I am worried about the kicking game.
LikeLike
As for Park the bad habits he learned may have been compounded by running the scout team but watching game film from his high school highlight film you can see that he rarely set his feet and read the defense. That tape looks more like back yard football. The kids has a gun but his footwork has been woeful for a while.
LikeLike