The Smart hire, nervous part edition

Change is exciting.  Change means hope.  But change means change, too. And I wouldn’t be completely honest if I didn’t admit to a certain amount of apprehension about how well Kirby Smart is able to do as Georgia’s next head football coach.  I’d say my concerns are two-fold.

One, and this is a generic issue, is that obviously Smart has never run a football program before.  It’s one thing to be a gifted assistant and recruiter.  It’s another to be the man.  That’s not to say he’s guaranteed to flop; it’s more like he’s not guaranteed either way.  We don’t know what he can do running the show.  The good news is that he’ll have a running head start on that.  But there’s no other way to look at it for now as a great unknown.  And, yeah, that makes me nervous.

The second issue, though, is anything but generic.  I guess the best way to describe it would be to ask what happens when The Process Meets The Georgia Way, for want of a better expression.  Kirby Smart has been at a place where it’s a given that everyone rows the boat in the same direction. That ain’t the way things have been in Butts-Mehre for a long time.

What happens with Georgia’s drug and discipline policies?  I doubt they change much, but at least it would be nice to know that somebody might put his foot down about scheduling a random drug test for players returning from spring break.  Also, there’s the question of money.  And that’s really two questions:  how much can be spent and how wisely can it be spent?  How much control Smart has over the purse strings will be some indication of how much success he’ll  have making the program go the way he wants.

I am skeptical, because, well… because there’s a track record at Butts-Mehre that’s hard to ignore.  If things really are ready to change, it could usher in a new era of greatness.  I’m not ready to make that kind of pronouncement yet… and probably won’t for a while.  But I’ll keep my fingers crossed.

136 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football

136 responses to “The Smart hire, nervous part edition

  1. ugafidelis

    Richt stays on for a bit to help the young one through the transition?

    Like

  2. Jared S.

    I think this is risky, but a good gamble to make. I think he’s the right choice from the available options. (But I would loved to have seen Richt coach next year, so what do I know?)

    Like

    • Jared, who were the available options? Nowhere on the UGA campus is there such a thing as a wide open search.

      Like

      • Jared S.

        I’m not saying they considered other options. I guess I’m saying, if they had, I don’t think they’d have found any other option that was less of a risk. Seriously. Unless they stole Meyer, Saban, or Harbaugh.

        Like

        • I can name three off the top of my head:
          1) David Shaw – may not have come without a big price tag
          2) Gary Patterson – may not have wanted the SEC stress
          3) Larry Fedora – probably would have come in a heartbeat rather than play 2nd fiddle to hoops

          Like

          • Chickamona

            I will weigh in on Fedora, as someone with a degree from UNC who lives in the Triangle and follows UNC football mostly as a diversion for when UGA isn’t playing (a school I also have graduated from) and for when UNC basketball hasn’t fired up yet. Fedora has had a great year, but in his nearly 4 seasons has had many maddening, bizarre “game management” moments that don’t leave anyone who has watched with a sense that he is sharp enough to do any better than Richt (see the 2013 UNC-Miami game for lessons in late-game coaching insanity or even this year’s game with South Carolina). Fedora also straight up botched his first defensive coordinator hire and had to bring in our buddy from the Plains, Chizik, to right the ship, as last year’s UNC team gave up 70 to East Carolina.

            UNC has also had the good fortune to avoid FSU and Clemson from the other division (along with pseudo ACC member Notre Dame) and enjoyed a very weak Va Tech and Ga Tech, a middling Duke and Pitt, and usual mediocrity from UVA. Not to discount this year, as they are a solid team and will be a tall order in the Dome next year, but if this 2015 UGA team was a 6-6 team (give them the 2013 schedule) hiding in a 9-3 cloth, this UNC team is probably a 9-3 or 8-4 team hiding in 11-1.

            TL:DR: Fedora has done a good job, but would not be an improvement of any kind over what we already had.

            Like

  3. Bulldog Joe

    If Smart is ‘smart’, he will address these scope-of-authority issues while he has the greatest leverage – now.

    Like

  4. MLB2

    Thank God it’s not Mullen. Time for us all to kiss and make up(except for Derek and Chili. You guys are comedy gold). I’m on board and hoping for good things. Go Dawgs!

    Like

  5. Hogbody Spradlin

    Kirby had the sense to stay in one place for 8 years, an eternity for an assistant coach. The same loyalty that makes me think Saban really runs the defense makes me think that Kirby has served the best apprenticeship possible. There is merit to the thought that he wouldn’t be pulling $1.5 million if he were just a place holder. One the other hand . . . .etc. . . .ad nauseam.

    Like

    • gastr1

      I have to agree. At the very least Saban has to have a pupil there who can be trusted to make the right calls & right game plan when the HC’s attention is elsewhere. Saban may have taught him, but he wouldn’t have him in this spot if the student hadn’t gotten past the student level.

      Like

      • Mayor

        Maybe Kirby can hire Nick Saban as his DC, then. That’s who really ran the defense at Bama not Kirby Smart. Kirby Smart=overpaid errand boy.

        Like

    • sniffer

      I’ve mentioned before my connection to Alabama. Married to a third generation alumni and socially have many large donors as friends. Folks, I gotta tell ya, “big” donors at Bama don’t have a card to get in the football offices. At gatherings, there is nearly as much conjecture as to the workings of the program as there is in a bbq joint in Statesboro. I’ve had conversations about Kirby with Bama people before. What’s been said is that he and Saban are on the same page defensively and Saban checks in about plans, but it’s Kirby’s defense. He is not Saban’s acolyte any longer. Don’t know if he can run a program but does know how to run the “defense” room.

      Like

  6. Tronan

    I am confident in Smart’s ability to successfully move from coordinator to HC. If anyone is prepared to make the jump, it’s him. There’s not an ironclad guarantee he’ll do well, but it’s a very safe bet (a bet, nonetheless) that he will.

    However, like you – like all of us, I’m sure – I sure hope he gets more autonomy than Richt did. B-M has been a hindrance, not a help, to athletics, and for UGA to field championship teams, this has got to change. (Related – forget about football for a minute – it’s mind boggling how our basketball and baseball teams are such also-rans.)

    Like

    • Red Cup

      Our hoops team has won 20 games the last 2 years and made tourney last year. Don’t think we have ever won 20 in consecutive years before

      Like

      • Mayor

        Reddie, I think that was Tronan’s point. In the over 100 year history of Georgia basketball how many 20 win seasons have the Dawgs had? Not many, even if the last 2 were back-to-back. Why? B-M, that’s why.

        Like

  7. 3rdandGrantham

    I keep hearing that ADGM absolutely would not capitulate on Pruitt, and Smart finally backed down at the end. If Pruitt doesn’t get the SCU HC gig and isn’t retained as DC, that will be very bad news for the program, as it will mean The Georgia Way is still in full effect.

    Let’s hope that all those power brokers behind the scenes who wanted change will finally stop meddling, get out of the damn way, stop playing politics, and stop with all the other deleterious nonsense so that Smart has a fighting chance of building a consistent top 5 program that, on paper, UGA really should be.

    Like

    • dudemankind

      Pruitt must have torpedoed his chances at UGA. I wonder if we will ever find out what truly happened a few weeks ago. I wish they would keep him around regardless. Anyway, McGarity’s fate is now tied to Kirby’s success or lack thereof. In the interest of self preservation he had better give him all the support he needs. The Georgia Way may be on the way out.

      Like

      • W Cobb Dawg

        I don’t want to be the guy who jumps all over the new HC his first day on the job – the ajc and 680 will do that. But if Pruitt would’ve stayed and Smart capitulated to McG, that’s a huge mistake.

        Like

        • Mayor

          Yes!! This means that we have the same old same old already in place before Smart has taken over. Query: If a new HC can’t even hire the DC that he really wants is he really the HC? Apparently McGarity is really the HC now. This is a clusterf#ck already.

          Like

    • Bulldog Joe

      Now I am hoping Ray Tanner Will finally get his coach named this week.

      Like

    • gastr1

      Do you guys think Pruitt managed to keep it in his pants while in Athens? –i.e., was his problem more than just personal abrasiveness?

      Like

    • If that’s the case, then the Way is in full effect, and GM is one vindictive SOB.

      Like

    • Pruit’s fate is all on McG.

      Like

  8. Biggus Rickus

    I’m cautiously skeptimistic on the hire. But it could be worse.

    Like

  9. Dawgwood

    I’m nervous he might put the black stripe back on the helmets

    Like

  10. Bro Tereshinski III

    Scene: Butts-Mehre, Kirby Smart’s new office

    Kirby Smart: We need to find ourselves someone to coach this offense. Let me take a look at this list Bobo sent me.

    (Pulls out list. Squints.)

    KS: Dangit, Bobo wrote it all in white crayon again. I can’t read this at all! Who am I gonna call that knows, let alone wants, to coach offense …

    (The lights in the room go out. Amy Grant begins playing over the building’s PA system at an incredibly loud volume)

    Scott Howard (who has seemingly appeared from nowhere, microphone in hand): BY GAWD THATS MARK RICHT’S MUSIC

    Eric Zeier (also appearing out of nowhere): NO. IT CAN’T BE.

    (Mark Richt struts, humbly, into the room.)

    SH: Who is that with him Z? Could it be?

    EZ: IT IS! IT…

    SH: NO… ITS IMPOSSIBLE

    EZ: THATS JACOB EASON WITH HIM SCOTT, HE’S GOT JACOB EASON COMING TO THE DESK WITH HIM

    (Eason enters, high fiving the fans lining the walkway to the desk. Again, no clue where they came from or how these smoke machines got in here. Richt continues to walk, eyes narrowed and focused in front of him).

    MR: Kirby

    (KS trembles)

    MR: Me and my boy here been spending some time down in sunny Florida… Wanted to let you know that. We’re tanned. We’re rested. We’re ready.

    (Richt grabs Bobo’s list from Smart’s hand and rips it up)

    KS: Does that mean?

    (Richt nods approvingly, puts on his sunglasses and lowers his straw hat.)

    Scene

    Like

  11. SAtownDawg

    would he have gotten the job if he wasn’t a UGA grad?
    is he a better DC than what we had last year?
    did we really fire Richt because boosters were afraid he would go to USC?
    is Boom really coming back?
    and finally, how many bold-face lies did our AD utter in the press conference? he really must take us fans as complete rubes

    GO DAWGS

    Like

  12. Scorpio Jones, III

    “The Process Meets The Georgia Way”

    That’s what I been talking about for a week. An irresistible force meets an immovable object.

    Its not about recruiting…we can do that.

    Its not about coaching…we can do that.

    It is about spending the money to win more football games…can we do that? Will we do that?

    Do we even know what that means?

    One thing is fer sure, they gonna be some interesting talks around the dinner tables up there in the North Georgia foothill lakeside dacha’s for the next few years.

    First candidate for the re-education camp in Hahira? The AD?

    Like

    • BMan

      “One thing is fer sure, they gonna be some interesting talks around the dinner tables up there in the North Georgia foothill lakeside dacha’s for the next few years.

      “First candidate for the re-education camp in Hahira? The AD?”

      Scorp, I’m not exactly sure why, but damn if those lines didn’t make me laugh my ass off.

      Like

  13. Jktom

    I am saddened by anyone (i.e., senator) that says we should reduce our standards to assure players doing something they should not be doing (smoking pot or taking any other illicit narcotic during spring break) are not identified and disciplined (talk about burying your head in the sand) – in others- these people are willing to sell their proverbial “soul” to reduce the risk of having a player disciplined for doing something they should not be doing in the first place. Standards do not get Spring Break as well. What kind of message does that send to these kids (rhetorical as I know the answer)?

    Like

    • gastr1

      So you’re saying that if a player went home to Colorado over spring break and legally smoked and toked, you support his subsequent testing & suspension, yes?

      Like

    • Red Cup

      Our competitors do not have a strict policy like ours. We are competing with a hand behind our back. How successful has the War on Drugs been anywhere?

      Like

    • RedRobbin

      That type of thinking is what has been holding the program back. There are plenty of ways to dicipline players without hurting the team’s chances to be successful. Adjusting the rules to be in alignment with the rest of the SEC is totally morally fine. If you really want your team voluntarily shooting themselves in the foot then check out tech Jktom.

      Like

  14. Good posts, Bluto. I agree that in a lot of ways, he meets the short term needs as well or better than probably anyone else could. But the long term, anyone’s guess is as good as anyone else’s.

    I know all the talk is about who the DC is gonna be, but for my money, the OC hire is gonna be way more important. Worst case scenario, Smart can always step in like Mason did at Vandy and take over the D if things get off track. So whether it’s Muschamp, Pruitt, whoever (ok not literally whoever, but you get my point), I’m not too worried about who ends up in that spot. I’d rather Pruitt be able to stay if given my choice, but not gonna sweat it either way. But if we don’t make the right hire at OC, it’s gonna be rough the next few years.

    Really hoping the rumors about Tyson Helton are true.

    Like

  15. paul

    Two things make me nervous. It seems to me if we are going to fire a guy who routinely wins 9-10 games a year for underachieving, shouldn’t we go after a proven commodity? Smart may turn out to be fantastic. And if he’s our guy then, of course, I hope he’s awesome. But when you’re giving a guy his first chance you never really know do you? Second, if it’s true that Smart wanted to retain Pruitt and he won’t be able to then I think we are already seeing that he’s not likely to be given the latitude to make his own decisions. CJP was the best thing that happened to this program in a long time. And last, okay three things make me nervous, are we really getting Boom because we can’t have Pruitt? Not only is that a downgrade, I can’t stand the thought of all the closeups of Muschamp about to burst an artery on our sideline. He needs to do that someplace else.

    Like

  16. Chickasaw

    Sigh. It is what it is. Guess I’ll get in line like a good Dawgie and support the new guy (though if he actually brings in Boom, I reserve the right to change my mind). But this is purely a gamble based on a hope based on a coordinator’s performance. Can’t believe we didn’t make a run at any current, high performing, experienced head coaches. Just astonishing.

    Like

  17. Derek

    What makes me nervous? Going with a spread guy because STATS! If you can recruit as well as I hope we will be able to it makes little sense to minimize your physical dominance playing a finesse offense. The identity we need to establish is the one Alabama has. We’re coming down hill and we’re kicking your ass until you quit. We need to be able throw well enough to keep up in games with teams that can score and run the ball well enough to where we can salt the clock with a lead. You create that sort of identity with the right talent and there are 9 teams on the schedule that need not bother to even show up because the game’s over before it starts.

    Like

    • Biggus Rickus

      You can do the same with a power spread, too. It’s a little too reliant on the QB for my tastes, but it can work.

      Like

      • Derek

        I realize that you can both be spread and physical. That’s what Ohio state does and I liked how they approached both of thier playoff games last year. For whatever reason, Meyer’s approach is in the minority among the spread teams. Winning football is about winning the line of scrimmage. Meyer knows that and does it out of the spread. So if we must, let’s be more OSU and less Baylor.

        Like

      • With our ability to recruit tailbacks, I don’t want a 4/5 star QB taking multiple unnecessary hits in a game. I loved watching Alabama run Henry out of the pistol this year (except on October 3). It looked like Gurshall in 2012 with Murray.

        Like

        • Derek

          Me too… I think that maybe we need to simplify the pro-style, multiple, balanced attack, to account for the short work week and variations in qb abilities, but there is an advantage to being different. Right now the spread is not unique. It’s standard issue. Alabama and Georgia and now UF are different. When the tools are there it’s “shit through a tin horn.”

          Like

        • Biggus Rickus

          I agree. It’s easier to find running backs to make your power game go than it is to find QBs who can do that AND throw well.

          Like

  18. To paraphrase loosely:
    AD:Do you take this coach to be your lawfully contracted spouse(coach( to honor, obey, and cherish . why yes I do.
    Coach: Do you promise to pillage, plunder, rip mayhem, destroy the SEC, and the national football scene, and to stampede cattle through the Vatican.
    Why sure I do.
    AD:Do you promise to give him anything he wants to pillage and plunder. Well yeah I guess so.
    Godfather: You may now kiss the underboss and main capo on the cheek.
    Coach: You many now do the same to the AD.
    I now pronounce you joined at the hip till death do you part,
    Coach: There was not anything in there about love honor and obey was there?

    Like

    • Forgot to continue:
      Coach: Well screw that love, cherish, honor and obey part. We do things my way.
      Crash, thunder,loud horror sounds from the AD and his bosses.
      Good luck to the new coach and good luck to UGA football.
      2016 is right around the corner.

      Like

  19. Debby Balcer

    If Boom comes and it is because Smart could not keep Pruitt it is a bad sign. Boom brings a lot of baggage and does not stay anyplace long and is slimy. Letting McGarity win that battle means Smart starts behind the eight ball. I do hope the OC will be good.

    Like

    • Derek

      Why is Muschamp “slimy”? I mean I know everybody is upset that’s he’s a nut case, but you know a bald man bloodying his bald head on players helmets isn’t exactly “staid.” We were MORE than ok with that. Will’s a mad man, but if he’s our mad man and coaching the defense well what’s the problem? We know he failed as a hc and we know he struggled to stop CMR (despite CMR’s terrible, regrettable offensive approach (sarc)) he can coach a defense.

      Like

      • Red Cup

        We do not need 30 yard penalties because he can’t control himself

        Like

        • Derek

          Can’t argue with that, but it’s once and only Auburn paid the price so… I mean it’s agent Muschamp: destroying our enemies from within.

          I agree that he shouldn’t have gone that nuts but we actually only saw what he did AFTER the penalty we don’t know what he did to get the penalty. I don’t think that we should discount Muschamp because if that incident. Frankly, thus far, his d stood its ground better against Alabama than anybody else has. That’s something.

          Like

        • Scotty’s play call are penalties enough, let’s not compound them.

          Like

      • I’m not upset that he’s a nut case. I don’t want him because he shit all over his alma mater (note the only school that would give him a scholarship to play ball; his dream coach Spurrier didn’t bother to leave the golf course to meet him) for some cheap laughs at a Gator booster event. Nobody begrudged the man for taking one of the best jobs in CFB, but there’s a way to publicly deal with your alma mater now being one of the biggest rivals of your new job and wanting to beat them every year without being a prick about it. Hell – Spurrier managed to do it at South Carolina with grace. Muschamp’s been dead to me since he made the “temporary insanity” comment.

        Like

        • Derek

          Whether they should say it or not we know that none of our former players in the coaching business are truly loyal to UGA. That includes the times when they are coaching here. They can’t afford to be. They will talk a good game next week about “home” but “home” is where the cash is. Besides if loyalty was what we’ve valued, we wouldn’t be having this conversation. We took a big giant dump on loyalty Sunday morning.

          Like

  20. Doggoned

    All in for Coach Smart. Please don’t bring in Muschamp. He makes my butt hurt.

    Like

  21. DawgPhan

    Smart is a DC. Our D was fine. We are now going to ask Smart to hire an OC. Something he has never done and it is the most important decision he is going to make. Making a poor choice for OC got the last guy fired.

    Boy we sure did set him up for success. good luck kirby.

    Like

  22. Obviously, there no guarantees that Smart will be a great head coach but he has been the DC at Bama for longer than Richt was the OC at FSU.

    Richt had two Heisman Trophy winners, won 2 National titles at FSU and played for a third one his final year there. In his seven years as offensive coordinator the Seminoles ranked in the nation’s top five scoring offenses on five occasions, were top twelve in total offense five times and top twelve in passing offense five times.

    Smart has been the DC for 3 national titles. His defenses have finished in the Top 5 nationally in total defense for 7 straight years.

    Much of the handwringing of this is tied to Richt’s longevity here and the Muschamp and Dooley failures. However, these branches of the Saban tree have been pretty good at coaching college football – Dantonio, Fisher, and McElwain.

    Like

  23. Russ

    Well, I was pretty “meh” about Mark Richt when they hired him, so I obviously don’t know much. However, I’ll really have a hard time getting behind Muschamp. The guy is an embarrassment on the sidelines, and I don’t think he’s an upgrade at all on defense.

    Don’t know anythink about the WKU guy, but I just hope we’re going to try to spread everyone out with a team that’s been recruited for pro style.

    And I still believe we hired a coordinator because he’s much cheaper than a proven head coach. We’ll pay Smart $3-4M which is much less than it would take for any proven head coach. Shaw would draw probably $7M, Herman probably $5M. The Georgia Way!

    Like

    • The WKU guy is Helton, brother of new HC of the true USC. May have some good genes, may be similar to the Harbaugh”s but may be younger.

      However, his hometown is Gainesville, FL not GA, LOL.

      Like

    • Russ

      Gah! I don’t English good.

      Should have been that I hope we DON’T try to spread everyone out with players recruited for a pro style.

      Like

  24. TMC dawg

    I truly believe that cultures will collide. The process vs the uga way. I hope Smart is the most stubborn Sob around. Am starting to see what Richt had to put up with. Hey Kirby, do what ever it takes to take us to the promise land. Even if it means giving Mccgarty the finger! go Dawgs!,,

    Like