If college football is seen as the NFL’s feeder system, what does that make junior college football for college programs?
The Big 12, Pac-12 and SEC combine to sign nearly 80% of junior college players who join Power 5 teams. No conference is as reliant on jucos as the Big 12, whose 10 teams signed 203 juco players in the last five years compared to the 65 signed by the 14 teams in the ACC.

The linked article reminds us that Georgia alone signed four juco kids in its last class.
So, it’s probably not good for college programs if jucos are facing tough times. Start with what drives almost every conversation about college athletics these days — money.
Figures range widely from state to state and school to school, but most within the junior college ranks believe every football program at this level loses money—some significantly. Take, for example, Itawamba Community College in Mississippi. The school spent $666,806 in 2016–17 on football, including more than $400,000 in salaries and scholarships. It made $17,436 in football ticket sales.
Scott Cathcart, the ranking junior college athletic director in the CCCAA, oversees athletics at Palomar College just north of San Diego. His annual athletics operations budget of $310,000 is so low that his 22 sports teams must fundraise about $200,000 each year. “We know we’re going to run out of money March 1, the fiscal year,” says Cathcart, who previously worked as an administrator at Temple. “It’s nothing like Division I. We’re not intended to make money. We’re intended to be educators.”
Juco football programs’ supporters would counter that even four-year college programs lose money—according to NCAA data, 46% of FBS teams finished in the red in 2016. There are other points to be made in their favor. Many states fund junior colleges based on their enrollment numbers, and football teams normally bring in north of 100 students, many of whom aren’t on any athletic aid. California’s football programs do not offer athletic scholarships, while about 60% of NJCAA football programs offer at least partial athletic scholarships, Parker says.
All seven juco programs in Arizona have been shut down due to funding.
Then there’s this recent development: “The big thing that’s killing us is this dang transfer portal,” Minnick says. Using the NCAA portal, many transferring players who traditionally would have dropped to the junior college level for a year are remaining in Division I now that schools no longer can control or limit their options.”
Add in that NCAA academic requirements for junior college players transferring to Division I schools (2.5 GPA) are more rigid than for those entering from high school (2.0), and you’ve got jucos being squeezed in every direction.
There’s a need for juco players (just ask Les Miles), but not so much of one that D1 schools are going to provide financial support (duh). Can jucos scramble well enough to save themselves and remain relevant?
I remember when Schembechler called Illinois the “Oakland Raiders” of the Big Ten because they were the fist school inn that conference to take a juco. He also said they were “The Harvard of the Midwest”.
LikeLike
Part of the reason for Big12 reliance is proximity. There are more jucos with successful football programs in the Midwest/Central Plains than in the rest of the country. Don’t ask me why that’s the case, I have no idea….but the jucos in the Plains have players from all over the country. For example…http://butlergrizzlies.com/sports/fball/2018-19/roster
Where the athletic population at the region’s sparsely-populated high schools is poor, a roster like Butler’s makes for more fertile recruiting ground. I doubt this changes much for the Big 12, because schools like Butler are the Power 5 of jucos.
LikeLike
It’s an intriguing article although I wouldn’t say it’s the canary in the coal mine. I would think other pipelines (FCS, DII, DIII) would all be options as well.
LikeLike
The other divisions you mentioned have not been pipelines like the jucos have. Players from those divisions have always had to sit out a year to prevent them from becoming feeder programs for the FBS schools. But, like the guy from the article says, the portal and immediate eligibility is changing that. What we’ll see happen is those divisions, especially FCS, being scouted and poached as a minor league for the big boys.
LikeLike
I don’t disagree — I think JUCOs have been pipelines for academic reasons. JUCOs are typically easier academically for all students and not just athletes. Get the blue chip eligible and hold on as long as possible has often been the approach. If JUCOs fall apart, I would think the other divisions of NCAA football would become more viable for poaching talent.
LikeLike
The reason why more juco players get signed out West is self evident. The most jucos that have football programs are in CA. Most of those juco kids didn’t get offered by the major colleges they wanted coming out of HS so they went the juco route. That works, too. A friend of mine was one of the top RBs in CA but got seriously injured his senior year and didn’t get any major college offers. He played a season of juco and got an offer from Cal, went there and played, graduated and is now a successful attorney. Juco works for players and it pisses me off the the NCAA has screwed juco up with the transfer portal. Doctrine of unintended consequences at work.
LikeLike
Shoring up the Juco systems would be a good investment for the Kids and the surrounding communities. It is a much better option than paying student athletes.
.
LikeLike
Schools are about as willing to spend their money on supporting jucos as the NFL is on schools. And for the same reason.
LikeLike
That is probably true. It would be nice o have constructive attention on this issue rather than paying the players. This would receive much more wide spread support.
LikeLike
If you don’t think that players getting at least a share of that giant pie isn’t favored by a consensus of the country right now, then you’ve got your head in the sand. This thing is snowballing, and the Zion Williamson episode currently has the issue front and center in the national media.
LikeLike
It’s no surprise the ACC doesn’t get it’s share. I would think that most players will want to play in the SEC, the PAC or one of the BIGs.
The ACC is to the point that Clemson will need to start apologizing for it’s joke of a path to the playoffs. The other formerly competitive teams are all weak sisters now.
LikeLike
I wonder if a pie chart of which conference blue chip HS players choose would sort of mirror this chart. I think it would be pretty close.
LikeLike
Damnit! We should have used the “Justin Fields should have to go to JUCO to help them out, instead of playing immediately at tOSU” defense strategy. We always F $h!t up.
LikeLike
Eh … Talent will always find a home on a D1 team. It’s not like we’re suddenly going to see schools not look at or find a JUCO Cam Newton type QB because, you know, The Portal! The Portal!
LikeLike
Jeeze. I enjoyed watching the first season of Last Chance U. Then you realize it’s just about emotionally unhealthy white men loving Jesus while yelling at black kids. And if you care about spending tax money wisely, it is quite obvious that it is a waste on JUCO football players. Sorry, but the SEC signing 25% of JUCO football players doesn’t say much for the wisdom of our country…but Hail Boy ain’t he a football player, as Rome burns.
LikeLike
Auburn spends more than 330 K/yr on FB and they’re a Juco, right?
LikeLike