Game of Thrones may have been HBO’s popular darling, but I’ve just finished watching two of the most impressive shows HBO has ever put out there, both of which were far more satisfying productions.
- Chernobyl is simply incredible. This five-part series is a drama, not a documentary, so while its attention to recreating the era is impressive, it’s not slavishly devoted to the entire truth. Details have been modified to make for better viewing, but the essential truth of the story is there. And that essential truth is both horrifying and compelling to watch. The horror is not just in watching what the nuclear accident wrought, nor is the herculean effort to prevent an even larger disaster all that is compelling. The best and strongest part of the story Chernobyl eloquently tells is the day-to-day horror of living with the consequences of a rigidly authoritarian society. If you’re trying to impress upon someone an appreciation for living in a free country, don’t shove them at a hack like Hannity. Plop them in front of Chernobyl and leave them to understand what they have.
- I’ll be honest with you. While I was excited to hear the news that HBO had approved making a Deadwood movie wrapping up the loose ends the series’ untimely demise left remaining and encouraged by the early words coming from the actors about the script, I still had concerns about whether they would be able to pull it off in a condensed format. I am here to tell you Milch indeed stuck the landing. (Yeah, it’s a little ironic he accomplished something in two hours that the GOT writers couldn’t in six episodes.) Deadwood: The Movie is brilliant in every way you might expect if you’re as big a fan of the series as I am. Okay, the plot isn’t much (although plot wasn’t really a big deal for the series, when you think about it), but the dialogue and the attention lavished on the characters, major and otherwise, shines. The story is a reflection on the passage of time and the toll it takes on people, which is a brilliant use of the real world time span between the end of the series and the movie. The acting is compelling; Olyphant, in particular, gives the best performance of his career. One thing I’ll say is that while it’s offered as a standalone story, it’s far more enjoyable if you’ve watched the three previous seasons. In any event, it’s not to be missed — especially Ian McShane’s final words, which constitute one of the great closing moments in the history of television.
Speaking of Olyphant, this is a little story that has to be shared (WARNING: minor spoiler alert):
… and Seth confronting Hearst in the thoroughfare with Dan and Johnny backing his play. After the first few takes of the latter scene, director Daniel Minahan gave Olyphant freedom to try alternate versions of Bullock’s scripted reply to Hearst threatening to come for him: “Expect you will, Senator.” Olyphant tried a few that neither of them liked as much as the original line, then noted that if this was Justified, Raylan would say, “Let me know, Senator. I’ll circle the date.”
Perfect. Reminds me of this line from Justified:
Add your takes in the comments and try to be mindful of others who haven’t seen either yet, but intend to. If you can’t avoid discussing something that’s a spoiler, at least warn the rest of us before you post your thoughts.
Really enjoyed Justified
LikeLike
Chernobyl was incredible; Jared Harris and the entire cast were a revelation. I’ve watched each episode twice now. Do yourself a favor and listen to the official podcast on YouTube with writer/creator Craig Mazin. Fabulous insight. This was just great TV.
LikeLike
Agreed. I second the notion for anyone who has not watched to listen to the podcast between episodes. Actually posted Monday morning on DV/247 about it as a PSA. I can’t remember a TV series that I enjoyed this much. I actually added Jared Harris’ spectacular line to my DV signature because I loved it so much.
“Every lie we tell incurs a debt to the truth. Sooner or later, that debt is paid.”
i have literally spent the last 5 weeks begging everyone in my work and social circles to watch it. The finale was as good an hour of television as I can ever remember. Though the final court scene was a one of the few times Mazin departed from the historical facts, the decision and manner in which he had Harris explain the chain of events was mesmerizing.
LikeLike
Chernobyl was, as you said, simply incredible. Firmly up there with Band of Brothers as HBO mini series go and maybe a notch ahead of Generation Kill and The Pacific (the former is painfully underrated and should be next on the list for anyone looking for options).
Currently rewatching Deadwood (midway through Season 2 now) as it has been a few years since my first time through and I want to regain my sense of the characters before I check out the movie. It was the most pleasant of surprises when I first tried the show out, having nearly completed Justified and Sons of Anarchy (enjoyable for entirely different reasons) only to find a show with Shakesperean western dialogue and some of the same principle actors as the aforementioned.
Not sure what to make of this upcoming Watchmen series or the hard reset of Westworld. Looking forward to Lovecraft Country and the mini-series adpatation of Wally Lamb’s I Know This Much Is True. Seems to be a split opinion on the adaption of Sharp Objects last year but I for one found it very entertaining to follow week to week; brought me back to that southern gothic theme that made season one of True Detective so enthralling.
LikeLike
I enjoyed the first season of Westworld, but the second season was a meandering mess. It doesn’t help that the show is so relentlessly misanthropic that even I, a card carrying member of the He-Man People Haters Club, found it to be a bit much.
LikeLike
Hindsight being what it is, we should have seen the piss poor end to Game of Thrones coming after the botch job of Westworld Season 2. When they played the teaser for season 3 before the GOT finale, I honestly thought it was a Blade Runner series before they flashed up the W on the screen. Really not sure how I feel about it; so much potential to have remained in the other parks and not completely detonate the concept so early like they did.
LikeLike
I honestly don’t have any interest in the third season and hadn’t seen that trailer. If people react favorably to it, I might check it out after it ends.
LikeLike
Generation Kill is absolutely outstanding! I highly highly recommend it next to BoB and The Pacific.
LikeLike
Chernobyl resurrected some long dormant nightmares. The sight of that blue “searchlight” pointed to space made my skin crawl. In reality it was a radiation field so intense it ionized the water vapor in the atmosphere. I need to watch the other four episodes.
Deadwood movie was excellent.
LikeLike
People can’t hack “The Pacific” because it is just too real and they don’t want their vision of America messed with. As for “Generation Kill” I think the title hurt and maybe “One Bullet Away,The Making of a Marine Officer” by Nathanial Fick (the series came from both books) would have made it more interesting to folks. If you have’t seen the panel discussion with they guys that were actually in the unit and the series. it is worth seeing.
LikeLike
I read Nate Fick’s book and saw the series. Enjoyed them both enough to do some follow on research. Fick’s Company Commander is a tech grad football player. SGM Sixta is doing ten years for child molestation. I’m not sure which is worse.
LikeLike
Not Captain America???
LikeLike
How ya doing, i84? I actually meant which is worse- a tech grad or child molester?
Captain America or CAPT McGraw is the type of officer who makes it essential to have a strong CO,competent fellow Platoon Leaders(Platoon Commander) and most importantly dedicated and tactful NCO’s with continuity of leadership. Someone should’ve snatched that shithead up by his stacking swivel and straightened his ass out long before they were deployed.
He was not like any Marine Infantry Officer I encountered.
LikeLike
I got the comparison 🙂
Sounds like I’ve got some reading to do. Thanks fellows.
LikeLike
Right I was asking if Fick’s CO was Captain America? That clown didn’t seem like he would have played ball anywhere. There were plenty of incompetent officers that I encountered in Vietnam and Korea but we were in a pinch and they took lots of people who should have never worn bars. You know, the best and the brightest had other priorities. We had a butter bar that took a jeep on the road before it was swept and got his driver and himself killed and another em badly wounded and that was in the frickin rear.
LikeLike
Okay. Captain Swetje was Fick’s CO. He was known as Encino Man by the enlisted. McGraw was simply a Platoon Commander.
LikeLike
Fick’s CO is not Capt. America. Fick’s CO is Capt. Schwetje (nickname Encino Man). Capt. America is the CO of Fick’s sister platoon. Both are comically bad at their job and I think both were pressed into action from other units. I know Schwetje was an intelligence officer before being assigned a combat command.
LikeLike
Thanks guys, it’s been a while since I watched it.
LikeLike
People don’t like The Pacific? I loved it, but I devour war stories so watching the messy side of war was not shocking.
Generation Kill is the title of the book the series is based on so I don’t think that was up for debate. One Bullet Away is phenomenal as well. I highly recommend it as a leadership book. Based on the testimony of the panel, it sounds like they got the series (and book) right.
LikeLike
I participated in an HBO Blog during the Pacific (you know how goofy they can be) and there were people complaining about the sex and the parts on Okinawa where the Marines shot civilians and took gold teeth. They thought it was terrible to portray Americans that way. I take my cue from Eugene B. Sledge. He told Studs Terkel “I’m not telling you how I wanted it to be, I’m telling you like it was”. I was watching “Band of Brothers” today and had forgotten the guy killing German POW’s so the reality of war was there as well.
LikeLike
Portray? They don’t know jack s— about war if they think the American soldiers are always saints or that our service members never get up to shenanigans while off duty. I’m with you. I trust Sledge to tell it like it is, not like he wished it was.
LikeLike
5×5
LikeLike
On the subject of “sticking the landing” to close a series, I can’t think of a better one than True Detective, Season 1. Perfect.
LikeLike
For me Band of Brothers was HBO’s peak
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m late into season 2 of justified. It is good but it doesn’t quite have the continuous thread that I enjoy with other series. It is almost an episode to episode series and not so much a long over arching narrative. It doesn’t hurt that I am a big fan of Thomasville’s Joelle Carter, She is great in the series and not very hard on the eyes.
LikeLike
First season was definitely that way, because it was strongly based on a book of Leonard’s short stories. As time passed in subsequent seasons, the story arc became unified.
Definitely stick with Season 2. It’s one of the series’ best.
LikeLike
Mags don’t take no prisoners.
LikeLike
The second season of Justified has the most compelling arc of the entire series, with the Bennetts. One of the things I really like about the show is how it mixes arc’d content with great standalone episodes like the one where Alan Ruck is the dentist / accountant on the run from a drug cartel.
LikeLike
There is a long overarching narrative that develops and continues between Raylan and Boyd that is damn near worth watching the show for all on its own. Eventually you get a sort of Dixie Mafia running theme with some of the bads that ties stuff together but it’s the Raylan-Boyd connection that you really end up staying for when it’s all said and done. Nothing quite like it anywhere else.
LikeLike
Each season has an arc after the first, though it is more traditional in its format than “prestige” series. Season 2’s is easily the most consistent season in terms of quality for me, but all of them but season 5 are good.
LikeLike
I enjoyed Justified all three times I watched it. I think my dad is working on his sixth time. He’s retired. I haven’t watched Deadwood, but because of Olyphant’s work in Justified, I’m interested in watching. Honestly, the description in the story line of Chernobyl, does not appeal to me, but since so many have raved about it, I may just check it out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Chernobyl was one of the best mini-series I’ve ever seen. Horrific and yet couldn’t wait for the next episode. The bleakness and constant heroism was staggering at times. Just a great great show.
LikeLike
The New Yorker has a fantastic interview with Milch about his struggles with Alzheimer’s while continuing to write. It is absolutely amazing the self-awareness he has regarding both his work and disease. Must reading if you’re a fan.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thoroughly enjoyed the Deadwood movie, started watching the series because the wife and I are going there in a few weeks. Felt like some of the characters were shoe horned in just to make an appearance but overall it was very good. Loved the cameo near the end, won’t spoil it for the rest.
LikeLike
Those characters (I’m guessing you mean Wild Bill Hickok and Calamity Jane) actually were in Deadwood during that era.
LikeLike
I meant like the Merrick the newspaper man, Aunt Lou, and some others
LikeLike
I’m irrationally angry that Justified didn’t get more love from critics (it’s far better than the overrated Breaking Bad for one) and Olyphant didn’t win at least one award for his portrayal of Raylan Givens. It hurt him that his best season, Season 2, was also Kyle Chandler’s Emmy year for FNL, but again, the most overrated show of the era got its admittedly great actor (Bryan Cranston) more awards than he likely deserved. Add Timothy Olyphant to the list of ridiculous awards snubs with Steve Carrell and Jason Alexander.
I’ve never seen Deadwood (because I never had HBO when it was on), but I recently bought the blu ray set, and I’ll need to watch. The behind the scenes talent (Milch) and the in front of camera talent (Olyphant, Carradine, McShane, Paula Malcomson, and so many more) makes me know it’s worthy of the critical praise.
Chernobyl is another one I’m sure I’ll get to eventually, but I’m doing a rewatch of Parks & Rec right now, and I’m on S3, the best season. Watching April & Andy finally get together and seeing Leslie & Ben fall in love amidst the craziness of Pawnee is sweet, wonderful, and hilarious.
I do agree with others here: I’ve seen every great HBO miniseries, and nothing is better, or will ever be better, than Band of Brothers. It’s not just the best of HBO, it’s the best, period. It is the crowning television achievement of all time in my eyes.
LikeLike
I had a close friend who was an 82nd Airborne WWII vet, and as a fan of military history in general, I had read Stephen Ambrose’s “Band of Brothers” before I watched the series. The book is has tons of quotes and witness POV, and goes much more into Sobel’s role and how it affected Easy. That being said, the producers of the series could not have done a better job of capturing the book on film. For me, the book is always better, but in this case the series really brought it to life. The casting was perfect as well.
Chernobyl is excellent. Deadwood is “Gritty” to say the least.
LikeLike
Band of Brothers was one of the few books that I have read and then watched the movie/series and was satisfied. Usually when they put it on the screen they take a lot of liberties with the story to try and make it more entertaining. With Band of Brothers, they remained faithful to the source material. One of my favorite scenes in of any production is where Winters (now a Major) encounters Captain (still) Sobel who attempts to walk on by like he does not see him. When Winters stops him and makes him “salute the rank not the man”… it just does not get any better.
LikeLike
I chuckled while reading the book because Lt. Compton, while known for being a star baseball player at UCLA, also played in the ’43 Rose Bowl.
LikeLike
Buck Compton became a DA in Los Angeles and helped prosecute the Manson family as well.
LikeLike
You’re right Tx Dawg. Both are phenomenal and that’s a great scene! I like Ambrose’s other WWII writing as well.
LikeLike
The only problem with Deadwood the movie is that we know for sure that it is now done and there won’t be any more. Adios to Wu, his pigs, and all the other cock sucking cocksuckers in Deadwood. We will miss you
LikeLike
Wait a minute…Wu? Is that the same Wu that used to post on the Dawgvent, come to Deadwood?
LikeLike
No man, Wu peed on my rug….
LikeLike
Wasn’t a huge Deadwood fan, when I watched the series a few years ago, just too depressing. I am, however, a huge Barry fan. Just started Season 2, three episodes in.
LikeLike
Has there ever been a better drama series than Mad Men?
LikeLike
The Wire, The Sopranos, Deadwood, Breaking Bad. Mad Men was a good top ten though. (My opinion of course 😂)
LikeLike
As noted Deadwood ending was perfect. Timothy Oliphant (well the writers) nailed it twice.
Chernobyl was unexpected. I did enjoy reading about differences between the movie and reality. Still some scary shit.
LikeLike
The opening scene of Chernobyl is definitely an “Oh shit” moment.
LikeLike
Looking forward to Chernobyl.
I’ve tried to start Deadwood a few times but can’t get into it.
LikeLike
Also: which service streams Justified?
LikeLike
Amazon Prime.
LikeLike
Thanks
LikeLike
I’m skipping all the comments because on the advice of this blog and a good friend, we’ve started watching Deadwood from the start. We’re all of one episode in.
LikeLike
The butler did it.
LikeLike
I’m still looking for the location of that Georgia whorehouse Swearingen’s mom worked in.
LikeLike
Effy’s maybe?
LikeLike
I admit I haven’t seen a lot of HBO series but I have thoroughly loved every bit of Band of Brothers, The Pacific, and Generation Kill. Band of Brothers is darn near perfect from any angle. The Pacific does a great job of showing the gritty combat of the PTO, which gets forgotten next to killing Nazis in Europe. Generation Kill stands out by showing the non-sanitized version of war. The source material comes from an embedded reporter rather than a historian getting a re-telling of the story years later. Gen Kill shows the daily living, irreverent banter, the frustrations with higher command, and the morally questionable actions that Band of Brothers only hints at from time to time. BoB has a lot more triumphalism in it while Gen Kill presents the raw material and lets you judge for yourself.
LikeLike
Add Westworld to the list of HBO great series.
LikeLike
Late. But …. Trump sucks.
LikeLike
The intelligence apparatus in the US, UK, AU, NZ and Italy also think so.
LikeLike
I wonder if AOC and the other Marxist in congress would come away with the same appreciation for our country after watching Chernobyl.
LikeLike