Andy Staples, then ($$):
College football’s chicken-egg argument is this: Is it more important to recruit better raw talent or more important to develop the players you sign? The answer, if a team wants to win national titles, is that it’s critical to do both. That’s what Alabama, Clemson and Ohio State do, and that’s why those programs have won five of the past six national titles. But in the case of Florida and Georgia, the Mullen staff seems to be superior in terms of development and the Smart staff seems to have the edge in recruiting. In truth, each will have to get better at the other aspect for their programs to frequently compete for national titles, but Saturday will provide an answer for what matters more in the present. A win by Florida is a victory for the chicken, while a win by Georgia amounts to a victory for the egg…
No one is getting fired this time unless things get truly odd, but the result of Saturday’s Cocktail Party certainly could alter the trajectory of one of the coaches in the rivalry.
Andy Staples, now ($$):
… Mullen kept winning on the field thanks to some special players he inherited — quarterback Kyle Trask was already on the roster and tight end Kyle Pitts had committed to Jim McElwain’s staff before it was fired — and that obscured the fact that with every recruiting cycle, Mullen’s Florida fell further and further behind Kirby Smart’s Georgia. Then it came to a head in 2021 after Trask and Pitts moved on to the NFL. Smart won the national title.
Mullen got fired in part because he helped point out the glaring difference between his attitude toward recruiting and Smart’s attitude toward recruiting with a bizarre freak-out about a benign question the Monday after his team lost to Smart’s Bulldogs. Mullen didn’t seem to understand that his job as Florida’s coach was to win the national title, and landing top recruiting classes is one of the basic requirements.
That 2020 Cocktail Party win turned out to be the biggest piece of fool’s gold in the history of Florida football.
You must be logged in to post a comment.