The Montana Project

It all started with Stewart Mandel getting medieval on college football’s ass.  Seriously.

How much can the perception of a program change over a half-decade? I’m not talking about the usual on-field ebbs and flows of going 10-2 one year and 7-5 the next. I’m talking about a real change in the national prestige (or lack thereof) a team established over decades due to its level of play in the past five seasons.

Plenty of you must be wondering, since I’ve been getting regular requests over the past year or so to revisit my “Program Pecking Order” Mailbag from August 2007 that divvied up the nation’s BCS-conference schools into a four-tiered Feudal society. This seems as good a time as any to do it. The genesis of the idea was a reader debate over whether Georgia should be considered a “national power.” My answer in ’07 was no (turning me into a permanent enemy of certain Bulldogs bloggers), and that hasn’t changed in the last five years.

As one of those bloggers, it wasn’t so much that I found his exercise questionable as I did his measuring stick.

… a national power carries “… a certain cachet or aura. It’s the way a program is perceived by the public. Let me put it to you this way. Suppose we went to, say, Montana. And suppose we found 100 ‘average’ college football fans (not necessarily message-board crazies, but not twice-a-year viewers, either) and put them in a room. If I held up a Michigan helmet, my guess is all 100 would know exactly what it was. … But if I held up a Georgia ‘G’ helmet, how many of them do you think would be able to identify it off the top of their heads?”

You can probably guess where this went next.

I wish I could claim full credit for what you’re about to read, but the reality is that I serve merely as the inspiration for Travis Fain, he of lucid idiocy fame, who sent me this e-mail a few days ago:

What if you and I worked to find a Dawg fan living in Montana, shipped him a UGA helmet, sent him to a sports bar and had him ask 100 strangers whether or not they recognized it? Maybe he, or even better, she, could have someone film it.

Is this idea ridiculous … or brilliant?

I think we all know the answer to that question.

Travis has dubbed this the “Montana Project”.  That works for me.

Despite some wondering what we were thinking, things took off rather quickly from there.  The key was finding a local volunteer who fit the bill for what we were looking for better than we could have hoped.

Hey and Go Dawgs,
The MT Project was made for me. My name is Hoppy and I am and tried and true Dawgs fan. Born in Macon my dad was a UGA grad and raised me to bleed the red and black. Since then, I have live in Great Falls, MT for the past 25 years and have rooted for the Dawgs every year. I have converted and ex girlfriend, my best friend and my wife to be part of the “Dawg Nation”.
My man cave is Dawg-centric and I buy the College-Game Plan package for the soul purpose of watching the University of Georgia Bulldog games!
I will gladly don a Dawg helmet and ask 100 people if they know what I am wearing.
I am a teacher and I share a room with a video production class; filming it won’t be a problem.
Will you really send me a helmet to wear? Lets figure out a game and I will head to the largest sports bar in town (its a legit sports bar, not some hole in the wall, po-dunk MT bar you are envisioning) and make the project happen.
I really think we will be in the high 80′s/low 90′s of people who know the “G”! Like one of the posts says, “Everyone knows that ‘G’”.
On a side note, my wife is from Glasgow MT and their high school has adopted the “G” as their own. It drives me bat-shit crazy. If I went to that town and did this they would all say “Glasgow Scotties”. Maybe 15 would say Georgia.
Go Dawgs!

Hoppy turned out to be a true mensch who lined up locations and help on the video front.  The only thing missing was getting one of these babies in Hoppy’s hands:


Fortunately for us, another Montana volunteer, GTP commenter Big Shock, stepped up and provided Hoppy with the helmet.  From there, it was just a matter of picking the right time to bar hop and asking the questions.

And so our baby was born.

That’s pretty much what a labor of love looks like.

Acclaim rolled in.  Even Mandel was impressed.  And Hoppy will never have to buy a drink in the state of Georgia for the rest of his life.


17 responses to “The Montana Project

  1. The other Doug

    Thanks Hoppy for making it happen. You are a DGD!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Greg

    I seriously doubt more than 70% of those people(especially the women) would have recognized a Michigan helmet.


  3. Nashville West

    Great job!!! Mandel is an a$$hat. Out here in California everybody recognizes my red hat with the black G. My daughter has a black Stafford jersey that she wears in Oregon and they recognize it up there too.


  4. POTD

    First, it’s just classic that a UGA fan doesn’t know how and when to use “a”, “an” or “and” when writing a paragraph. And he’s a teacher…named “Hoppy”. We are doomed.
    Second, when you walk up to a table of 8 people and the first person replies “Georgia Bulldogs” of course the rest of the table will follow suit. So instead of a 73-27 final tally (and one Yea vote was clearly coerced) I would estimate the real final tally would be something like 68-32.
    And unless you went to UGA, we all know a score of 68 is a FAIL
    OK, I’ll give you a D+. But good effort though!


    • Dawgaholic

      Uhh, there were other people at tables with multiple that answered differently.
      Also, not sure I’d count people that think Georgetown has a football team, or that think the Georgia Gators were a possibility. Doubtful they are more than 2 game a year fans.


  5. Pingback: The Montana Project comes home. | Get The Picture

  6. Pingback: College football program pecking order 3.0: Dividing all 66 BCS teams into four-tier hierarchy - WXXV 25

  7. Pingback: “It’s a certain cachet or aura. It’s the way a program is perceived by the public.” | Get The Picture

  8. Pingback: Moving to Montana | Get The Picture

  9. Pingback: Postcard from Montana | Get The Picture

  10. KornDawg

    This is way late, but it relevant to the subject and I wanted to share. My wife recently had an encounter at a home improvement store here in SC. She was having a gamecock key made for someone and the employee asked what the logo was. My wife explained to her that it was the logo for the state university. As it happens, the employee isn’t from around here. So my wife showed her the UGA logo and said “this is the team you should follow.” The employee said, “Oh yeah, I know that team.” Where was she from? Montana.

    Liked by 4 people

  11. Pingback: You were always on my mind… | Get The Picture

  12. Pingback: Another GTP offseason project | Get The Picture

  13. Pingback: Arise, King Georgia. | Get The Picture

  14. Pingback: De la Géorgie, enfin élevée, à 5 équipes désormais paysannes : les Kings & Barons de Stew Mandel - The Last News

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s