Shall we play a game?

I’m officially taking a temperature reading with this post.  We had less than two dozen folks participate in last year’s Mumme Poll, and, frankly, it’s not worth the trouble to run it for that few number.

And given that I satisfied myself a few years ago that approval voting was a less biased way to rank college football teams, the only reason Tidefan and I keep the Mumme Poll going is for the sheer enjoyment of participating.  So, unless there’s sufficient interest in keeping the MP in play, I intend to shutter it for good.

Let me know in the comments if any of you are still interested in casting ballots.

Advertisements

My Mumme Poll ballot, Week 13

Thanks, Stanford.  You made my ballot selection easy this week.

• Alabama
• Clemson
• Oklahoma

Really, that’s the fastest I’ve ever put a Mumme Poll vote together.

My Mumme Poll ballot, Week 12

And then there were four.

• Alabama
• Clemson
• Notre Dame
• Oklahoma

Quite a few games to keep my eye on next weekend, though.

Mumme Poll, Week 11

Things keep consolidating, which makes sense.

 

Rank	Team	Votes
1	Clemson	27
2	Alabama	26
2	Ohio State	26
4	Oklahoma State	24
5	Oklahoma	22
6	Notre Dame	18
7	Iowa	15
8	Florida	10
8	Houston	10
10	North Carolina	6
11	Michigan State	4
11	Baylor	4
13	Toledo	1
13	Michigan	1
13	TCU	1
13	Navy	1

 

More to come after this week.

My Mumme Poll ballot, Week 11

This past week is the perfect rebuttal to all the idiots in the media who waste time fretting over the selection committee’s rankings in November.

It’s also a good reason to cull teams from my ballot, which is getting leaner and meaner… with more to come, I suspect.

• Alabama
• Clemson
• Notre Dame
• Ohio State
• Oklahoma

There.  That didn’t take long at all.  (Although, yeah, I’m keeping an eye on Iowa and Oklahoma State.)

Mumme Poll results, Week 10

Well, we’re not exactly on the same page with the selection committee.

Rank	Team	Votes
1	Alabama	23
1	Clemson	23
3	Ohio State	22
4	Baylor	20
5	Oklahoma State	19
6	Stanford	16
7	Notre Dame	14
8	Iowa	9
9	Oklahoma	8
10	Houston	5
11	North Carolina	4
12	Florida	3
12	LSU	3
14	Utah	2
15	TCU	1
15	Navy	1

Three out of four.

We are starting to see consolidation, though, as only sixteen teams received votes.  And no doubt we’ll see even more over the next couple of weeks.

Not that it means too much, but given that Florida lost to LSU, I’m kinda surprised to see the two tied.

My Mumme Poll ballot, Week 10

With LSU’s loss and TCU’s, I had to rethink my ballot for the first time in a couple of weeks.

• Alabama
• Baylor
• Clemson
• Notre Dame
• Ohio State
• Oklahoma
• Stanford

I’m pretty sure the Big 12 is overrated this season (which is why I omitted Oklahoma State from my ballot), but not positive.  Another week or two of games should sort that out.  Same thing with Stanford and Notre Dame.

At least I’m down to seven teams this week.  But up to ten minutes to put my ballot together.