Another wild night

This year’s version of Georgia football isn’t for the fainthearted.  On the one hand, you can only shake your head as you watch silly mistakes compound defensive lapses to put the team in an eleven-point hole on the road in front of a hostile crowd.  On the other, you watch the same group of players and coaches maintain their poise and go on a seventeen-point run of their own to quiet that same crowd.  From that point on, it was simply a question of whether the Dawgs could stay out of the way of their own formidable talent long enough to win the game.

At least they managed to put their opponent away a minute earlier than they did the week before.

Offense

Joe Cox is turning out to be one of the most interesting stories of the season.  His week to week improvement has been staggering.  And his team has needed every drop of it.  For him to wind up outplaying Mallett is just remarkable.

The other big story from last night is the rapid emergence of playmakers all over the offense.  King, Charles, White and Moore all had big plays to complement another huge game from AJ.  King and Samuel combined for more than 150 yards rushing.

Line play is still not what you’d expect, given the talent and Stacy Searels.  Some of it, like the run blocking, can be explained by Arkansas’ decision to sell out to stop the run by loading the box (I swear I thought I saw ten in the box at least twice last night).  But Arkansas got a better pass rush than I expected, which was disappointing.  On the other hand, when the offense rolls up well over 500 yards and 52 points, the line must be doing some things very well.

Bobo, overall, did well, I thought.  Despite the numbers Arky put out to shut down the run, he refused to abandon it, which was good once he also decided to let Cox take his shots exploiting the coverage in the secondary.  And he didn’t panic with the crazy lead changes in the third quarter.  He also did well going back to the run when the Hog defense started backing players out of the box as Georgia’s passing game took its toll on the scoreboard.  His offense earned every one of those 52 points.

Defense

Martinez and his charges are challenging one of the axioms of football defense before our very eyes.  We’ve all been taught that it’s a primary goal of a defense to shut down the run and make an offense one-dimensional.  Georgia’s succeeded in making teams throw the ball in its last two games.  Unfortunately South Carolina and Arkansas have both happily embraced the opportunity.

Martinez had good game plans in the first two weeks, but last night was a different story.  The lack of a consistent pass rush continues to plague the defense (Houston sure had a quiet night from that standpoint, for the most part), but his defensive backs looked completely lost on several occasions.  There were receivers running free on almost every play that Georgia ran out of its base defense.  And it seemed like everybody in the stadium knew the play action call was coming on Arkansas’ last touchdown, except for the Dawg defense.

You can’t hope that dropping eight men into coverage against a quarterback who grew increasingly erratic with his throws and decision making is going to be a successful strategy every week.  Martinez also needs to figure out why his line is so good at stuffing the line of scrimmage in stopping the run, but remains feeble at getting after the quarterback – even a relatively immobile one like Mallett.

Special Teams

The punt exchange in the fourth quarter was huge.  And it capped a very good night for Drew Butler (55+ ypp average, with three kicks inside the 20).  Walsh was flawless on extra points and field goals.

But kickoff returns were nothing special.  Georgia was erratic on kickoff coverage.  And two directional kickoffs went out of bounds (I await the lesson for the fans on that).

Punt returns, meh.  After the disaster of the first one, it seemed like all the Dawgs cared about doing after that was staying out of the way of any more screw ups.

Miscellany

— To win by eleven on a night when you go -2 in turnover margin and rack up an astounding 14 penalties, most of them not of the “that’s what happens when you play aggressively” variety, is amazing.  It helped considerably that Arkansas had penalty problems of its own – particularly that spectacular meltdown after Cox’ interception that wound up negating any momentum or field position advantage from it.  Georgia is now -7 in TO margin on the season, yet is 2-1 (2-0 in the SEC!) after playing its third game in a row against BCS conference opposition.  I don’t know how you do that.  I also don’t know how you can expect that to hold up over the course of a season.

— From the department of early season stats:  Georgia is now averaging 46.5 points per game in conference play.  All of you who expected that, raise your hands.

— Given the smack talk, AJ’s touchdown catch over Broadway was the most satisfying play of the season to date.

— I cannot begin to express the words of gratitude I have for swapping Brad Nessler for Mike Patrick on play-by-play.

— UGA VII is one mellow bulldog.

— Arkansas sure likes whining to the officials.  Speaking of which, given the pace and the sloppiness, I thought last night’s bunch did a good job calling the game.  Both of the turnover replay calls were made correctly.

— Arkansas has an impressive receiving corps and Mallett’s got one hell of an arm.  Still, Georgia managed higher yards per catch and yards per attempt numbers on the night.  Not too shabby.

— For all of the offensive fireworks, both teams were less than stellar on third down conversions.

— Georgia won the time of possession battle for the first time this season, so there’s that.

— I loved the cojones Richt showed on both the fourth down conversion and the two point play after the penalty.  Shades of Les Miles…

51 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football

51 responses to “Another wild night

  1. Batdawg

    If we can ever manage a turnover-free, minimally penalized game, we can play with anyone on our schedule

    Like

  2. Darryl Strawberry

    Woaaaahh…hold on. We dont need Les Miles. (but i know what you are saying)

    I gotta say, i have never seen WRs 30 yards down field with a defensive back no closer than 10 yards away.

    Hell, on the TE throwback (which is such a great play btw, that i expect us to utilize now with Orson Charles) Cornelius Washington made the tackle 30 yards down field. great play by him, but pathetic play from our DBs.

    Like

  3. JaxDawg

    I had hoped the 2008 UGA D was an anomaly.

    It was not.

    To that I ask – if you fire Martinez you know RG will be expecting the promotion. Is he capable or will firing Martinez mean losing RG as well?

    Either way, our D needs an overhaul. Expeditiously.

    Like

  4. Brandon

    I’ve had the same feeling after our games the last two weeks that I used to have when Rocker came in to close a game for the Braves, walked the bases loaded and then struck out the side. The feeling is part luck, relief, and awe at the potential. Unfortunately, I have the nagging feeling that this can’t last, we all know we can’t continue to turn the ball over like this and be sucessful, and unless we get way better on defense Florida may score 100 points against us in Jacksonville. We are an eyelash away from being 0-3, but if we had a real defensive coordinator we would be national championship contenders, sadly that defensive performance last night was absolutely Goff-esque (and I don’t throw that term around lightly). With that said I am really proud of our players and their resilence and effort, Ryan Mallet is the biggest whiner I have seen in some time, and holy cow Drew Butler is some kind of weapon as a punter, he saved our bacon several times last night. Maybe we’ll get it together on defense, it would be something to see if we did, but I’m not counting on it.

    Like

  5. papadawg

    “I cannot begin to express the words of gratitude I have for swapping Brad Nessler for Mike Patrick on play-by-play.”

    I could not agree more!

    Like

  6. Doc

    I believe some apologies are in order to Joe Cox. drdawg76, RaleighDawg, JaxJay, hartwelldawg, mattr, Egatch, I am looking at you.

    Like

  7. Turd Ferguson

    I’m really trying not to jump too quickly onto the anti-Martinez bandwagon. I almost did it last week, but ended up convincing myself that it was more a combination of (a) Garcia having a career performance, (b) Spurrier having the smarts to take what we were giving him, and (c) poor execution on our part.

    I’m having a harder time this week, though. Granted, SOME of it was execution. Brandon Boykin looked positively awful. And it was a frozen Bryan Evans that allowed one of those touchdowns. But c’mon, isn’t the secondary supposed to be Martinez’s specialty? He’s the DBs coach, right? How in the world could our entire secondary look this bad, collectively, two weeks in a row? I don’t want to take anything away from Garcia and Mallett, but they’re not THAT good.

    Also, I was happy to see Caleb King have a decent night. Hope he keeps it up.

    Like

    • Will (the other one)

      I also disappointed to see that when we would get LBers or D linemen going towards Mallet, not a one got their hands up when he threw.

      Like

  8. Apparently, WM traveled to Big 12 country over the summer to learn some of their schemes. It’s working!

    Like

  9. baltimore dawg

    these days, i’m highly satisfied by any kind of win, and as long as that’s all that matters, i guess i’d prefer to watch a high-scoring shoot-out rather than a defensive slug-fest. i’ve essentially given up on the hope that the dawg defense returns to the quality of play we used to be known for.

    i’ve never called for firing anyone, mostly because firing under-performers for the sheer satisfaction of it is not really a strategy for success–if i thought there was an obvious and immediate up-grade opportunity at dc, then you make your move. the situation with garner, as the other commenter noted, is a real complication, though.

    but i am just as sure that martinez is a mediocrity, at best. give someone like rashad jones to charlie strong or nick saban, and he’s a first-team all american *last* year.

    Like

  10. JasonC

    RE: 4th down
    Maybe Richt is reading “Smart Football”. Now, if we can just get the assistant coaches to do the same.

    RE: Willie and the defense
    I was only able to see the first half, so things may have changed, but it was interesting to see us get torched last week by playing zone and then equally burned this week playing man. I have never seen so many jump balls in a game (on both sides).

    Like

  11. ERK VANRUSSELL

    richt has cojones? HAH! im suprised he didnt apologize to arky that we hung 50 on em

    Like

  12. Joe B.

    Martinez was facing two of the great offensive minds in CFB history the last two weeks, and all of his DB’s are freshmen/sophomores, except Prince, who has looked awful all season, and Bryan Evans, who is in his first season at DB.

    We will not see a QB nearly as good as Mallett the rest of this season. He made some throws that I do not think Stafford could make. There were several deep throws on which our DB’s were in perfect position, Mallett just beat them with an NFL throw.

    Good lord, if we just do not drop the ball on our side of the 50 TWICE, we win this game by 3+ TD’s!

    Willie is not having a great year, but if we keep dropping punts and pitches with no defensive players within 10 yards, the defense is going to keep having a tough time.

    Butler’s punt was the play of the night. It just shut the crowd down and really cut Petrino’s playbook in half. Helluva year that kid is having.

    Like

    • Joe B.

      Pardon me, Evans is in his first year at Safety.

      Like

    • JaxDawg

      Joe,
      These problems can be traced to Jan, 2006 vs. WVa.

      They did not begin with the past two games.

      Either you are uninformed or myopic.

      Martinez is NOT the solution. It is what it is – the stats do not lie.

      Do you recall Tech and Kentucky from last year?

      Do you recall Florida and Alabama?

      I have maintained my hope that 2007 was the norm not the exception. Time has proven that it is not. Florida’s young guys played lights out in 2008 – so I do not by the “youth” excuse.

      Statistically, we are a shell of the former Junkyard D.

      No one, regardless of their love for GA football, can argue against the facts.

      Like

      • Joe B.

        I certainly agree with you about the loss of swagger after the sUGAr Bowl debacle.

        Greg Blue ran his mouth all week before that, then got embarrassed.

        Then we had ’06 when we could not stop Kentucky and Vandy from going down the field in the 4th quarter.

        Then we had Ufk, 2007, and our defense simply failed to show up.

        I do not think that Willie should be back next year, and I am very disappointed with the defenses failures since Van Gorder left.

        But, I do not remember Van Gorder’s defenses having to go right back on the field many times after our punt returner dropped a ball on the thirty, or our RB inexplicably dropped a pitch on the 35, or our star WR handed the ball off to the opposition on the 15 yard line.

        Unfortunately, we see these things from our offense every week now.

        Arkansas started about three of their drives last night on their 35 or worse. I do not think they scored on any of them.

        I am very frustrated with the defense, but happy to get win.

        Like

        • Brandon

          Martinez has had the benefit of better offenses than Van Gorder had, I remember BVG’s D keeping us in game after game until the offense finally made some plays, the back-ups used to play great in mop up duty when BVG was here that was the first thing I noticed go. Also, it didn’t start at the 06′ Sugar Bowl, the Auburn game that year was atrocious defensive, that was the first time I remember GA scoring 30 points and losing a game since Richt came in 01′.

          Like

          • Will (the other one)

            Actually, prior to the 2005 Auburn game, Richt teams were undefeated when scoring at least 20 points I think.

            (Plus, LSU’s national title team was the only one to break 30 points on us at all.)

            Like

  13. baltimore dawg

    one more thing: it should be noted that caleb had his best game, and most heartening of all were the two vicious blocks he laid down in pass protection that i saw. i was worried that he might not have any fight in him–i was wrong.

    Like

  14. benmul8

    baltimore – great point about Caleb — as much heat as he took for his poor blocking last year, he deserves props for putting in the work to improve. Like you said, he leveled people a couple of times, so it looks like he’s actually turned it into a strength. Kudos, Caleb.

    Like

  15. Some guy

    Okay, so Arkansas defense — not so much improved!!

    Like

  16. Irishdawg

    I’ve tried to be fair to Martinez, but the last two games have been inexcusable. Yeah, the offense and special teams have put them in bad spots, but they’ve also haven’t dominated anyone, except for AZ State last year, since 2007. Van Gorder’s defenses were fierce, WM’s, not so much. Richt really needs to make a play for Kirby Smart.

    The offense looked like a machine last night, and this team could really do damage with a decent D.

    Like

  17. Wolfman

    I think Arky called one fantastic game on the offensive side of the ball. Yeah, the defensive output was incredibly frustrating, but I remember being wowed more than once at some of the things they did on offense. Not saying we can’t step it up on D, but kudos to their scheme.

    And, yeah, huzzah for the step up to Nessler. If progress can continue and we can swap Nessler for Uncle Ron, I’ll be a happy man.

    Like

  18. SCDAWG

    Irishdawg, I’m with you on the Kirby Smart play. Garner will expect a promotion and if he doesn’t get it….well Georgia might have to replace him. I don’t think from a coaching standpoint it will be a problem , but recruiting may be another story. Kirby can recruit as well.

    Janzek has to go as well. LBs ( besides Rennie) aren’t picking up coverages either.
    Has Georgia had a great set of DB that played the pass great? I mean Thomas Davis and Greg Blue would both get burned on the pass. They had Pollack hazing the qb back then to help the situation.

    Bryan Evans is an absolute joke back there.

    I asked thhis the other day: Would either of our Coordinators be a great pickup for Alabama, Florida or LSU?

    What is really going to piss DAWGNATION off is when Crompton looks like a 1st rounder against this defense.

    Like

  19. 69Dawg

    The D has problems too numerous to mention. Our DB’s are getting 3rd degree burns from the wideouts blowing by them. B Evans can not cover a one legged man. He waits for the wideout to get to him before he reacts, both at SC and Arky.
    If he is the best we are screwed. Our LB’s including Rennie are not good at covering TE’s or the backs out of the backfield. I don’t know if it’s the scheme or the personnel but a good play action passer (see GPOOE) will eat us a live.

    We had better hope that the D’s we face are not a lot better than SC and Arky cause we are playing tennis matches and one side out gets you beat.

    Like

  20. NRBQ

    20.8 yds. per catch. 14.4 per ATTEMPT. Wow.

    Obviously, we coulda, and shoulda crushed ’em.

    I still think we need to try and run with power. It brought back horrible memories watching those sprint-draws again. Samuel tried to take one left on second and 12, no gain. Penalty. Then we run the exact same play on 3rd and 18. No gain. Did CMR call those plays?

    I’ll watch Arky vs Bama with interest. I don’t expect Mallett and Co. to look like the same team against Bama’s D.

    Like

  21. Irishdawg

    “Garner will expect a promotion and if he doesn’t get it….well Georgia might have to replace him”

    I hope that’s not the case, but what has done to show he deserves the DC job? He’s as much a part of the defensive failure as Martinez. We need a fiery DC that is able to make in-game adjustments and disrupt good offenses, and Smart is my first choice, since I doubt Will Muschamp is going to leave Texas.

    Like

  22. BigOldDawg

    Gosh, and here I thought the defense stopped them when the game was on the line, at the end, and suffered through four turnovers and drive-stopping offensive penalties and stopped them three times when the game was on the line at the end.

    I really appreciate all the insight about how bad our defense is.

    From now on I will wish for the bend but don’t break philosophy of Erk Russell, who is the gold standard of Georgia defense, not Van Gorder.

    Boy, do I ever remember the Junkyard Dawgs, who gave up yards all over the field till the game was on the line and they had to have a stop, and got one.

    Gosh, wish they played like that now.

    Like

    • JaxDawg

      BOD,
      with all due respect, Erk Russell would bitch-slap WM and the entire defensive staff after 2008 and 2009 to date. Sure their were Erk squads that had down years (see 1977, ’79) but rarely did they continually allow 30+ points each and every week!

      For the life of me I cannot understand why some knowledgeable Georgia fans continually fail to see the simple truth re: our Defense. The talent is there guys but the coaching is clearly not.

      DJD, are any of you old enough or capable or remembering the Kevin Ramsey/Joe Kines period of 1999? For those that do, tell me how many starters from the ’99 and ’00 squads were drafted and have since started in the NFL?

      For all the sick talent of those defensive units, we continually underperformed. It sure as hell wasn’t talent. The answer to “why” was just as obvious then as it is today.

      To deny CWM and staff’s inadequacies as coaches is simply denying that the sun rises in the east. Sadly, some folks believe the sun revolves around the earth.

      Like

      • Brandon

        Here, here.

        Like

      • Hackerdog

        The Dooley/Erk fans remind me of my grandfather. He could never understand why a waitress deserved more than a $2 tip. The answer is that times have changed.

        Erk gave up plenty of yards and points to the offenses of his day. But he never had to defend the spread, or Mumme/Spurrier pass-happy offenses. Yards and points are more plentiful these days.

        I’m not arguing that CWM is a great coach. But stats can be misleading. The South Carolina game is the perfect example. We gave up lots of yards and lots of points, but only one extended touchdown drive.

        If you tell me before we play any team on our schedule that our defense will only give up one long touchdown drive, I would feel pretty good about our chances.

        Like

    • baltimore dawg

      gosh, gee–i don’t know bigolddawg, boy. i’m old too, and i don’t hardly remember too many occasions where it was necessary for dooley to rack up 50 points to cover for erk’s bend-don’t-break defense. gosh.

      Like

      • Hackerdog

        That’s because racking up 50 points was nearly impossible in the SEC during the Dooley/Erk years.

        The best offenses in the SEC would average, what, 28 points a game? Offenses chewed up clock and yards in the hopes of outlasting the defense late in the game. Now, offenses are chucking the ball all over the field, sprinting to the edge, and trying to take every snap to the end zone.

        Times have changed.

        Like

        • Scott

          I agree that offenses have changed since the Erk days, but why do we have accept being at the bottom of the conference in defensive stats?

          Why can’t we give up 25 td’s per season like Alabama, Florida, Tenn and the other conference powers?

          We gave up 42 td’s last year! How is it that Vanderbilt consistently outperforms UGA on defense?

          Like

          • HackerDog

            I think the relative rankings of defensive statistics are the best argument against Martinez remaining the DC.

            But every statistic has a story. Last year it was injuries and poor special teams play, turnovers, and penalties leaving our defense to defend a short field. We could have done better, but with the handicaps we faced, I doubt even the best coaching would have put us at the top of the defensive rankings.

            I simply take exception to the argument that Erk was a better coach because his defenses surrendered fewer points. You may as well argue that Charley Trippi was better than Hershel Walker because Trippi played both ways. It’s apples and oranges.

            Like

  23. Scott

    30 or more points only 1 time (34 points by LSU in 2003 SEC title game).

    Martinez – DC for 55 games. Opponent has scored 30 or more points 13 times. (Auburn 31 pts. and West Virginia 38 pts. in 2005); (Tenn. 51 pts in 2006); (Tenn. 35 pts, Florida 30 pts., and Troy 34 pts in 2007); (Alabama 41 pts., LSU 38 pts., Florida 49 pts., Kentucky 38 pts., Georgia Tech 45 pts. in 2008); (South Carolina 37 pts., Arkansas 41 points in 2009).

    Like

    • Will (the other one)

      Over the last 10 games, we’ve been giving up an average of 31.1 pts/game. Since 2007? Over 26.

      That’s worse than Ramsey…

      Like

  24. SCDAWG

    Baltimore, my thoughts exactly. I guess old dawg is saying Willie Martinez is Erk Russellesque. Yeah, top flight schools are falling all over themselves to snatch Willie from Richt.

    Tebow and Company are going to kill Georgia. If this defense made Garcia look good…wait til Tebow dink and dumps to Raines and Demps.

    I will go a step further and say Jeff Owens and Geno Atkins aren’t as special as folks thought.

    As far as a replacement, screw Muschamp. I think he is over rated. Georgia has hung some serious points on his defenses and Texas Tech was hitting some passes last night.

    Another question. Is Willie Martinez a MNC type coordinator? If he isn’t, why would you expect national recruits to come play for Georgia?

    I want to see Pugh play in Evans spot. What is the worst that can happen? He get burnt? Like that isn’t happening now with Evans.

    Like

  25. Scott

    In 46 red zone opportunities last year, we forced 9 FG attempts the entire season. This is really the most glaring weakness of CWM. The opponents always convert scoring chances. We never forced many field goals. Our red zone td scoring defense has been atrocious under CWM. Good D’s will allow TD’s about 40% of the time in the red zone. We were at 63% last year, and over 70% against conference opponents.

    Are our schemes too soft or passive in the red zone?

    If you look at other defensive measures from 2008 or other years, we place much better in conference rankings. But when it comes to scoring defense, we were 11th in 2008. There are teams like Auburn that give up more passing yards, total yards and have worse numbers in yards per rush or pass. But Auburn gave up significantly few points than UGA because Auburn forced more field goals and played better in the red zone.

    Certainly, the poor kickoffs made for a shorter field for our opponents, but we gave up 29 red zone TD’s (last in the Conference) and 42 TD’s overall (only Miss St. gave up more touchdowns).

    Like

  26. Yeah, I haven’t updated this, but it’s not going to be any prettier. WM is Kevin Ramsey’s bitch!!

    http://gatriguy.blogspot.com/2008/11/its-worse-than-we-thought.html

    Like

  27. HamDawg11

    If Mallet doesn’t go brain dead in the 4th qtr and miss open receivers, then we’re talking about why we lost.

    It wasn’t great defense that stopped Arky late in the game, it was Mallet’s arm.

    Like

  28. Mayor of Dawgtown

    Well, since the subject of WM was brought up, if he is replaced, who with? Who is the best DC in college football (leaving out Lane’s daddy)?

    Like

    • Scott

      John Tenuta might be looking for work if Charlie Weiss gets the boot.

      Among current DC’s from Southern schools and ranked among the best DC as per rivals.com:

      1. Greg Hudson, East Carolina
      BUZZ: He has done a nice job rebuilding what had been a shaky defense. His defenses make it a priority to stop the run and also thrive on forcing turnovers. Last season’s defense led C-USA in total defense and scoring defense.

      2. Tyrone Nix, Ole Miss
      BUZZ: He was a coordinator at Southern Miss and South Carolina before moving on to Ole Miss, and has had a great deal of success. He is a former linebacker (at Southern Miss) and his defenses usually are in an attack mode. Mix, 36, should be a prime head-coaching candidate soon.

      3. Ellis Johnson, South Carolina (no longer DC)
      BUZZ: Johnson doesn’t have the coordinator title with the Gamecocks any more, but he still will call the defenses this season. Johnson did great work at Mississippi State before moving on to South Carolina last season. His defenses are aggressive and physical.

      Like

  29. Scott

    THE TURNOVERS EXCUSE for CWM:

    85 turnovers from 2005-2008 (52 games)

    2008 — 19 UGA offensive turnovers

    2007 — 17 UGA offensive turnovers

    2006 — 31 UGA offensive turnovers

    2005 — 18 UGA offensive turnovers
    _________________________
    83 turnovers from 2001-2004 (52 games)

    2004– 19 UGA off. turnovers

    2003– 18 UGA off. turnovers

    2002 — 23 UGA off. turnovers

    2001 — 23 UGA off. turnovers

    ** each one took a week off of my life expectancy

    Like