Notes from a scrimmage

So the first 2015 scrimmage is in the books.  Contrary to my jokey post yesterday, Richt did release a fair amount of information about it and where things stand in many areas at this point.

First, here’s a stats summary.  So there’s that.  It should be obvious that the stats from any scrimmage that ended without Nick Chubb generating any yardage – or touches, for that matter – should be taken with a grain of salt. And it’s clear if you listen to what Richt had to say yesterday about the scrimmage, that he took the numbers in context.

Still, there was more to take away from yesterday than I expected.  On to the bullet points:

  • Richt’s demeanor.  He’s almost always laid back in these settings (except when he’s responding to a Chuck Oliver question), but there was a certain sense of calm in how things are progressing that emerges as you watch him answer media questions.  It’s not that he was blowing smoke; he acknowledged there are several areas of concern.  What comes across to me, though, is a feeling that there haven’t been any big surprises so far. When you consider the overhaul of the offensive staff, that’s not a bad thing.
  • The offense.  Evidently it’s been going through growing pains through the first week of spring practice, but smoothed out some of the rough edges in the scrimmage.   Per Richt, “We looked more like an offensive unit today.”
  • Center.  It’s not as high-profile as the battle for the starting quarterback position, but the search to replace David Andrews is important in its own right.  Yesterday, Isaiah Wynn received the first-team snaps at center, followed by Hunter Long.  This is pure speculation on my part, but my guess is that the coaches would prefer for Wynn to emerge as the starter, simply because Long is a senior and if he winds up as the first-teamer, it means they have to go through the same shuffle at the position next year.
  • Injuries on offense.  They’ve made something of a mess at running back and wide receiver, which is why Quayvon Hicks is now getting training at yet another position, tailback.  There are only seven or eight healthy receivers right now, which makes the math kinda shaky when the coaches are trying to run three teams out there.  On the other hand, it’s kind of nice to see some serious production out of Justin Scott-Wesley.
  • The quarterbacks.  Basically, no surprises at this point:  “There were flashes by all of them at certain times,” Richt said of three quarterbacks, who are competing to succeed Hutson Mason. “Sometimes they’d drop back and do exactly what they were supposed to do and throw beautiful strikes. … And then there were some times where you shake your head a little bit. They all have to learn that every play is not going to be successful and sometimes you’ve got to throw the ball away.” Gee, where have we heard that before?
  • The defense.  Obviously the big statistical story was Jake Ganus’ day, but keep in mind he was working second-team.  More interesting to me is that Jarvis Wilson, an early enrollee at defensive back, keeps doing enough to get attention (although Richt makes a point of talking some of that down).  With the job Pruitt did with Sanders last season, any db who steps up early is worth keeping an eye on.
  • Isaiah McKenzie.  The one surprise from Richt’s presser was the way he gushed about McKenzie – as a receiver.  We all saw a lot of promise from him last season – he ran routes pretty well and did a good job with separation – that was tempered by a case of the dropsies at certain key moments.  So to hear Richt say “He’s got good hands” makes me hope he’s about to step up and become a key contributor on offense.  Sure would be good timing for that.

Anyway, that’s what I saw.  What about you guys?

70 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football

70 responses to “Notes from a scrimmage

  1. I am really happy to see A.J. Turman finally getting to practice full speed. He has been more that patient with those injuries.

    Like

  2. sectionzalum

    Nice to see AJ Turman actually playing ball.

    Like

  3. doofusdawg

    Another good thing is that it appeared cbs let the guys throw the ball down field. With all the negative accusations about cbs running a dink/checkoff passing game… the offense sure did put up some numbers.

    You mentioned many of the positives… one other is Jay Rome who looked to have had a long catch. It would be a real plus if he and Jeb can stay healthy all year. I can’t imagine a stronger tight end one-two punch anywhere.

    Like

  4. EdDawg

    QB:
    Park completed 57% going against the 3rd team defense, Bauta was at 57% vs the 2’s, Ramsey completed 50% against the 1’s. Good to hear Park & Bauta as usual did not throw too many int’s, on the other hand, Ramsey continues to throw INT’s at a Joe Cox pace–it’s concerning considering he played with the 1’s and had the best backs, receivers, and linemen. Ramsey averaged 7 yards per pass, Bauta 8, and Park averaged an eye popping 27 yards per pass. Ramsey continues to look like the annointed one per Richt’s preferences, but continues to play like the 3rd best Qb statistically. I know he played vs the No 1 defense, still, 50% accurate, 2 picks, and 7 yards per pass, a terrible day again for him. I don’t see what Richt likes in Ramsey, maybe he’s the nicest one, nothing else makes sense, his numbers just continue to disappoint. Bauta or Park are producing when given chances, no one seems to notice among the coaches. Looks like Richt’s mind is already made up and his Qb will be Ramsey due to experience and niceness, Ramsey kind of reminds you of a combination of Joe Terishinski & Joe Cox in he has the most returning experience, kindness, and statistically inaccurate and interception prone. Looks like Bauta and Park have the best arm from their yards per pass. Bauta’s numbers looked like a starting Qb, 57% accuracy a little low, but the 2 td’s and 1 int and 8 yards per pass, all pretty good.

    Injuries:
    The WR’s and RB’s are, as usual, banged up with injuries. At some point, someone has to start looking as the leadership of the S & C, they simply are not good at injury prevention. And it has cost many games. My biggest concerns at both positions have already happened, with the exception of a Chubb injury. Not good news at all.

    RB:
    4th, 5th, and 6th string here, so I don’t know what to make of that, Hicks did impress with 8 yards a carry. AJ got 6 yards a carry. Douglas really never does anything have no idea why he got 14 carries he as he didn’t earn them with his production at 2 yards per carry, give another guy the ball.

    Defense:
    Couldn’t stop 4th and 5th string back ups, AJ got 6 ypc, Kicks got 8. And the secondary got torched for 5 td’s and 666 yards passing. YIKES!

    Field goals:
    Morgan 2 of 4 on field goals???

    Sacks?
    My guess is most of the 6 sacks were on Ramsey, as Bauta and Park are extremely mobile. this is another concern. Can anyone disconfirm thisi?

    Like

    • You make me wish Mark Richt had followed his first instinct about releasing stats.

      Like

      • EdDawg

        I give credit where it’s earned, the defense got torched by backups, field goal kicker missed 50%, the offense, besides Ramsey and Douglas, was impressive and did this with a lot of back up receivers and rb’s.

        Confirms my feelings about the defense were right on, looked like an 8-4 team, we are going to have to outscore opponents to win.

        If Chubb stays healthy and has a Heisman type year and we go with Bauta or Park, you never know, we very well could outscore everybody.

        One intriguing idea is the Jacob & Chubb combo, if they come up to stop Chubb, Park goes deep. If they drop to cover deep pass, Chubb gashes them.

        Like

        • You are making observations about players whom you haven’t seen on the field, based on stats from a scrimmage setting for which you have no way of determining how they were compiled.

          The technical term for this is “talking out of your ass”.

          Like

          • EdDawg

            My hunches have been consistently right on over the years, I rarely miss. And Richt has not picked a Championship Qb since 2005, so he’s been 0-9 since 2005.

            Time will tell if Ramsey is an SEC Championship Qb leader and how good Bauta and Park are.

            Like

            • Mike Cooley

              The first sentence in this post nearly made me wet my pants I laughed so hard. The conviction of it was freaking gold.

              Like

              • Dawgoholic

                Dude, if you’re not a troll, you need to focus on something other than college football because you don’t have a clue.

                Like

                • EdDawg

                  Oh it’s quite the opposite. Richt has won 2 SEC Championships. He has 2 formulas. I’ve got 2 big clues for you.

                  Clue 1- do it with defense
                  In 2002 he had a top 5 scoring defense.
                  This formula only works if you have a top 5 scoring defense, and as you can see from the scrimmage and the 800 yards of offense the defense yielded, that formula will not work in 2015. This has worked for Bama

                  2- Do it with a dual threat Qb
                  In 2005, Richt went with daul threat Qb DJ Shockley. This is really Richt’s only option if he wants to learn from his championship formulas. Forget the drop back 1 dimensional Ramsey, go with dual threat Bauta or Park. This worked for Meyer at UF, and Auburn in 2010 & 2013.

                  Like

                • RocketDawg

                  Thomas Brown….is that you? Clever of you to change your name again so you can come on here and spew your nonsense. Go back to your own blog and “like” all of your posts again under your new name. That way they will all have two likes instead of one.

                  Like

                • EdDawg

                  Have you seen Forrest Gump? You would like it.

                  Like

                • Thomas is pretty easy to spot on here. When you see someone new yammering about meaningless stats fifteen different times in the same thread, that’s good ole TB.

                  Like

                • EdDawg

                  Aww, we have Thomas brown in the house (aka RocketDawg), he who smelt it, dealt it, what up Thomas?

                  Like

                • ellis

                  Just to be clear, this was a spring practice scrimmage.

                  Like

            • The Quincy Carter of Accountants

              “And Richt has not picked a Championship Qb since 2005, so he’s been 0-9 since 2005.”

              This is a really good point. I went back through the archives and did some research and I think there might be a pervasive talent evaluation problem here. Not only has he not selected a championship quarterback since 2005, but it appears he has failed to select a championship center, offensive guard, offensive tackle, tight end, full back, tailback, flanker, split end, defensive end, nose guard, inside linebacker, outside linebacker, cornerback, safety, kicker, punter, or returner in the same time frame. I would have thought that any coach worth his salt would have selected at least one championship player in that time.

              Like

              • I was going to ban ED, but you guys are having so much fun with him, I think I’ll wait. 😉

                Like

              • EdDawg

                So, let me get this straight, a punter is as important as a Qb? Ok, we got it QC.

                Like

                • The Quincy Carter of Accountants

                  You have not gotten it straight.

                  In every year Richt has won the SEC he has, by definition, chosen an SEC championship quarterback. It is the same for any position – only the condition of winning a championship makes them a champion [insert position here].

                  So one of two things has happened in your analysis of Richt’s quarterback picking. 1) your statement is tautological or 2) you were just being vague and your point was “Georgia hasn’t won an SEC championship since 2005 because Richt hasn’t picked a sufficiently good quarterback.

                  If it was option 1: The prevention of tautologies in serious rhetoric like college football blogs is all that separates us from beasts.

                  If it was option 2: you’re entitled to your opinion but if you think seriously thing that Matthew Stafford and Aaron Murray were what kept us from a national championship, I don’t think your position makes sense.

                  Like

              • EdDawg

                NFL pays Qb’s more than all other positions, obviously, it’s the most important.

                http://www.businessinsider.com/nfl-highest-paid-positions-2014-9

                Like

      • Scorpio Jones, III

        No shit, bro.

        Like

      • Was thinking the same thing. The stats do more harm than good because fans can’t (or won’t) contextualize them.

        Like

    • Debby Balcer

      Nothin good to see? If you think Richt picks his QB because he is the nicest or next one you are looking through negative glasses. His choice of QB has always been right.

      Like

      • EdDawg

        Joe Terishinski and Joe Cox were not good choices. Richt hasn’t picked a Qb who has won an SEC Championship since 2005.

        Like

        • ACM

          So, who was better in 2009 than Joe Cox? Couldn’t have been Aaron Murray. We know he was terrible because he came up yards short in 2012 (I still can’t figure out why ole #11 couldn’t stop those Alabama running backs).

          And then, Joe T in 2006 – who should have beaten him out? Can’t be the aforementioned Cox. And Stafford never took us to Atl either, so he’s out.

          I think CMR really missed out on the QB dynasty he could have had. Think about it – Blake Barnes to Logan Grey to Mettenberger. National championships all over the place with that crew.

          Like

          • EdDawg

            Look, if you think Richt’s 0-9 record since 2005 in picking Championship Qb’s is great, fine. I don’t and msot perople don’tt agree with you and Debby that’s that’s great.

            Richt has forgotten how to pick Champions, leaders, at Qb. Mett or Mason over 3 years would have been a better choice than AM. Mett’s tearing it up int he NFL and AM isn’t, so those guys who know football agree with me. Mason went 4-1 vs ranked teams, something AM could never do in 4 years, have to think 3 years w/Mason or Mett = SEC Championship.

            Like

            • ACM

              And yet Stafford made the Pro Bowl and Tim Tebow is basically cold calling NFL teams asking for a tryout, so I’m not buying the idea that because Mettenberger played in his first year in the NFL and Murray didn’t that Mettenberger would have won more championships at UGA (and, in fact, Mettenberger had two years in the SEC to try to win championships with teams that were arguably as talented as ours during that time – and he couldn’t).

              Nobody’s fine with not winning championships – but it’s ridiculous to think the primary cause is that Richt repeatedly chooses the wrong quarterback.

              Like

              • EdDawg

                Cool, you’re one of the few ok with Richt’s record at picking Championship Qb’s since 2005, I’m in the vast majority that sees room for improvement in that area.

                Probably is the No 1 reason Richt has gone on the winless Championship streak since 2005.

                I also feel it’s one of Richt’s biggest blindspots, so people have to try and point it out, because he thinks he’s great at picking Qb’s, or else he’d change and fix it.

                Like

                • Dawgwalker07

                  “Probably is the No 1 reason Richt has gone on the winless Championship streak since 2005.”

                  You’re an idiot if you seriously think who has been playing QB has been the biggest reason we haven’t won a championship since 2005.

                  Like

                • EdDawg

                  Is 7 the number of anyone’s IQ you know?

                  Like

            • Dave

              Epic trolling….trying to steal Eason away maybe? Or just bored?

              Like

              • EdDawg

                What? I’ve said in the past, any QB should definetely come to Georgia, over 80% of season QB starters at Georgia go on to the NFL. Nice try, next time, try asking me about my intention instead of attempted smears, ok Bro? If you want to know my intention, next time, ask.

                Like

            • gatorhater27

              Yeah Mettenberger is tearing it up so much the Titans are probably gonna take a qb with the number two pick in the draft.

              Like

    • The Quincy Carter of Accountants

      I’ll defer to Allen Iverson: Man look, I hear you… it’s funny to me too, I mean it’s strange… it’s strange to me too, but we’re talking about practice man, we’re not even talking about the game… the actual game, when it matters… We’re talking about practice …

      Like

      • EdDawg

        So, if it’s JUST a meaningless practice, why report the stats? Why call it something different than practice? We don’t report stats from other practices, so this must be more important. Richt himself has said it’s very important, the Spring halfway point, an excellent measure of where his guys are right now.

        Like

      • EdDawg

        Richt said this about Sat’s scrimmage in Timesfreepress, 3-28-15, articleGeorgia’s Barnett enrolls early, only to wait :
        “We had a little shorter practice today because tomorrow is very important,” Bulldogs coach Mark Richt said. “It’s the first scrimmage of the spring and practice number seven. We’re almost halfway through. We’ll find out where we’re at tomorrow.”

        So, according to Richt:
        1- this scrimmage told him where he was at
        2- This scrimmage was very important.

        Like

    • Bazooka Joe

      Dang Ed, glad you are not the coach !

      Like

  5. Goat Balls

    I’m rarely ever wrong in my predictions too, and I’m thinking that most of the teams that we face will surrender before kickoff and forfeit. Except for the idiot Gators and we will kick their weasel butts.

    Cheers and God I hope Pruitt is as good as I’m thinking he is.

    Like

    • EdDawg

      what an intellectual post. you’re so right, Pruitt’s defense was great today, held the offense to just 6 touchdowns and under 900 yards.

      Like

  6. Goat Balls

    Yep, he’s a gator troll. Slurp my balls kid.

    Like

    • EdDawg

      Gators? Not a fan at all. Their coaches are weak. Talent isn’t there. Bunch of first year coaches. What specifically made you erroneously think I was a Gator fan junior?

      Like

  7. RocketDawg

    Senator can you please boot this asshole ^^^^^^ at best he is a troll and and at worst he is an actual “fan” who thinks that he knows something about the game (clearly not).
    I love coming hear to read and comment but this jackass is almost too unbearable to put up with.

    Like

    • EdDawg

      RocketFailedtoLaunch, sorry I didn’t type stuff you agreed with. My mind reading skills are fading. Tip for you: Try making some type of relevant comment on a blog instead of trolling every once in a while ok bro rather than trying to get people kicked off for disagreeing with you?

      Like

  8. EdDawg

    Calling someone asshole, or slurp my balls, idiot, etc, even though it’s very likely the same dude typing all his blather, never on point to your article, trying to smear people who disagree with him, I would think you didn’t prefer people to write stuff like that…

    Like

    • Cosmic Dawg

      I may not agree with you (I think you’re trying to isolate too few variables to explain “championship” football) but I agree that you’re getting unnecessarily bashed by people who aren’t making much effort to argue your points on their merits.

      Like

      • EdDawg

        Thanks ‘Cosmic’, doesn’t bother me. One correction though, in my opinion, it’s not ‘people’, it’s just 1 guy, he’s been doing this for years, he makes up these fake names/sock puppet posts to attempt to make it look like more than 1 person agrees with him, his characters all basically never post on topic, attempt to discern my, according to him, always evil intentions, and just hurls curse words and insults and says the same thing over and over like his character Thomas Brown, it’s hilarious really, and he created this blog with this character called Thomas Brown, he tries to associate with me, I’m flattered by someone that would go to all the trouble to attempt to imitate me, but there’s only one me, and I couldn’t agree less about any of the stuff his character(s) spews, but you’re right about one thing, it’s because he can’t argue his points on merit. He’s not good at spirited debate. Just my opinion. When my points get really logical, that’s when the attacks start it’s usually 5 or 6 of his characters all agreeing with each other and saying the same thing, very predictable.

        I admit I’m a bit like Larry Munson with seeing the negative sides of things, but damn, every post I write is intended to help the team fix something and you won’t find too many bigger fans.This guy would have hated Larry Munson, would have thought Larry was too negative. Larry was the biggest fan.

        Like

      • EdDawg

        If you’re open to a respectful discussion, I’ll try and respond. You wrote: I think you’re trying to isolate too few variables to explain “championship” football. I’ll tell you where I was coming from in a way I’ve never explained before.

        Richt has tried this formula now 12 times:
        Pro Style Passing Qb + top 25 defense. It has failed all 12 times.

        I won’t repeat the 2 formulas I found that were different in 2002 & 2005, so just read some of my posts above to figure them out but in 2002 & 2005, Richt did not use the Pro Style Qb + top 25 defense and he won the SEC Championship both times. So, what was different in 2002 & 2005 to you since you disagree with the causes I came up, if you got something with a higher correlation than the 2 formulas I have mentioned and can back it up with statistics, I’d love to see it? Also, if you look at Bama’s 3 National Championships in 2009, 2011, and 2012, what do they all have in common, what was their biggest strength? And the 2 years Bama didn’t win it, 2010 & 2013, Auburn did, what did Auburn have in common both times as their biggest strength? Just looking for formulas why SEC teams have won the SEC recently, or Richt back in 2002 & 2005. I see formulas that Richt can use and I am frustrated he doesn’t see or use them.

        Like

        • The Quincy Carter of Accountants

          Damn it – until I got to this one I thought you were serious the whole time. You got me. Well done.

          Like

  9. EdDawg

    I for one, was overall blown away by the offense. I didn’t expect it to look this good this early but a lot of credit goes to Coach Schott, he really had his guys ready to play, they put on some fireworks. I didn’t expect him to dominate this soon, but it’s certainly a very good sign of things to come. Schott used the tight ends more, which was something Bobo was very poor at. Also, the playcalling he made must have been terrific, as the offense just rolled, no matter who was at Qb, RB, or WR. Very impressive showing by Coach Schott.

    Like

  10. Cojones

    Looks like O and D did pretty well. Unstoppable force vs immovable object. They were getting after it on both sides. Hegedus not going at it with the tweaked hammy, but was surprised of no stats on the monster trio. All in all, it looks like a good go in the first scrimmage with everyone gettin’ down to bidness..

    Sic’em Dawgs! You have us breathing heavy.

    Glad we aren’t dealing with discipline now like we used to after Spring Break. Good that it was taken early also since there was a shootout with 7 people shot this weekend at ONE party that featured a few AA&M students.
    Weather too cool to enjoy the beach at PC so, unless you were in the Keys, indoors was the only party place. That invites outside crashers and local shooters in return, except in this case, that wasn’t quite the makeup contributing to the incident.

    Like

    • pete

      I know it is way too early and we don’t know if some of the plays were situational, but the thing that stood out to me was Ganus leading in tackles with 10. I was skeptical about his ability to compete but it looks like he is getting after it. It remains to be seen if he can maintain a level of play that will get him on the field in real games.

      Yep. It is good to see we survived spring break. For once I’d like to see a full complement of Dawgs start the year.

      Like

      • pete

        Oh, I forgot to mention Malkom Parrish. I wonder what a “big-time” pick looks like. 🙂 I believe MP will contribute this year…

        Like

        • Cojones

          From the looks of this first scrimmage, I see tons of ballplayers waitin’ to get into the game. I feel good about conditioning and number of available good players to the extent that “tired on D” will never hit out Lexicon again.

          Like

  11. EdDawg

    Check out these 11 receivers yards per catch averages among the receivers:
    Matt Price 64 yards per catch
    Reggie Davis, 41 yards a catch
    Clay Johnson, 20 yards a catch
    Kenny Towns, 17 yards a catch
    Wesley, 16 yards a catch
    AJ Turman, 15 yards a catch
    Mitchell, 15 yards a catch
    McKenzie, 14 yards a catch
    Blazevich, 14 yards per catch
    Harris, 13 yards a catch
    Rome, 12 yards a catch

    Like