Offensive malpractice

This, in a nutshell, is what drove me crazy watching the game last night.

Kolton Houston knew the final play, or what proved to the final play, was in good shape when the Georgia left guard got to the line and saw Georgia Southern had bought into the three-wideout look, and had two safeties back.

“They were in the perfect look,” Houston said. “And I said: This play has got a chance to spit. And sure enough she went right down the pike.”

Sony Michel did indeed go right through the middle for the game-winning 25-yard touchdown on Georgia’s first play of overtime. The blocking on the play was perfect, and Michel did the rest.

But the rest of the game didn’t look so good blocking-wise for the Bulldogs, at least from afar.

It didn’t look that good up close, Seth.  But I digress.

The offensive line has struggled for a good part of the season.  To make matters more challenging, the staff decided to undertake a wholesale reshuffling of the o-line for Georgia Southern.  That, in turn, invited the exact response Georgia got from the Eagles’ defense.

“They definitely dialed up and brought everything but the kitchen sink at us,” Theus said. “They were twisting and bringing stunts and all kind of pressure. We had to respond to it, but we did a good job, had a good gameplan for it. And tried to make out adjustments as best we could.”

They blitzed.  They stunted.  But basically they loaded the box every opportunity they could.  And what was frustrating about that was that Schottenheimer had a very obvious counter at his disposal, which was to play out of three- and four-wide sets.  Especially with the latter, those forced GSU to play with six defenders in the box and that meant Michel had room to operate.  Add in that the Eagles’ secondary was nothing special in pass coverage, and it was an obvious tactic to stick with.

Unless you’re Brian Schottenheimer, I guess.

I’m definitely not someone who qualifies as having been in the arena, but it’s straight out of Offensive Coordinator 101 that your playcalling should start (and end) with taking what the defense gives you.  Instead of sticking with that, we saw a bunch of I-formation and twin-tight end sets that were nothing more than an opportunity to flood Georgia’s offensive line with more defenders than it could handle.  That’s exactly what they got, too.

Theus was honorable enough to deny that the personnel changes had an effect, but you couldn’t help but see that Long was overmatched and there were communication problems throughout the game.  Yet, Schottenheimer kept calling plays that left them susceptible to GSU’s scheming.

This, again, is part of a pattern I’ve seen this season of setting players up to fail that’s been the worst part of the coaching job we’ve gotten out of the staff this season.  It smacks of the approach they took with letting Bauta start the Florida game, while limiting his first team reps in practice and not altering the game plan from what hadn’t been working.

I don’t get it.

66 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football, Strategery And Mechanics

66 responses to “Offensive malpractice

  1. Turd Ferguson

    Not our place to criticize coaches. Schottenheimer knows more than we do. The players just must not have executed the way they were taught. Not a single OC in the world who could get more out of our talent than Schottenheimer is getting. So everyone just lay off.

    Like

  2. ncdawg

    I have been hearing most of the season about how the offensive line has not looked good. Although I agree to a point, they have been working against run loaded defenses for most of the season. Although they have not been effective in opening run lanes against 8-9 defenders each play, I have not seen our quarterback(s) on the ground in sacks either. The offense has been abysmal this season, but I really feel like the O line deserves more credit than they are getting.

    Like

  3. Russ

    Worst OC coupled with bad QB givess us this slow motion disaster.

    As someone else said here, Richt hitching his wagon to Schotty is stupid and dangerous for his career.

    Like

  4. Brandon (Version 1)

    Regardless of what happens with Richt or Schotteinheimer, I think we owe Schotty a debt of gratitude. He has showed a generation of Georgia fans who had no solid frame of reference what truly bad offensive coaching is. I have always supported Richt but if Schotteinheimer coaches for us next fall I will be prepared to flip the switch.

    Like

  5. D.N. Nation

    Schottenheimer is not a good OC. Full stop. There’s nothing in his CV to think that this year is an anomaly, either.

    I didn’t necessarily agree with the worst-hire-ever talk in the offseason. I thought it was an uninspired, safe pick, but that he’d bring in a couple new wrinkles and leave well enough alone otherwise.

    But no, it truly is the worst hire ever. He’s put his boss’s job in the balance. I don’t think he actually knows or cares what he’s doing.

    Like

    • I called it a terrible hire when it happened and received no shortage of vitriol. The signs were there for anybody who wanted to look. His offense in St. Louis was mediocre to bad, he’d never spent any significant time coaching the college game, and it reeked of a guy just taking a job to avoid being unemployed and on our part, a sign that no one worth a shit wanted to come here.

      Like

      • adam

        No way we couldn’t have made a great hire last year. We looked to have all the right pieces to have a good offense. Richt’s job looked pretty safe. The defense was expected to take a big step forward. We pay a lot of money and offered a 3 year contract. We could have hired someone excellent. It will be a lot harder this January, but it’s still a good gig.

        Like

        • gastr1

          Richt’s lack of flexibility with the scheme is increasingly an issue. It’s why we don’t have DeShuan Watson; it’s why we do have Brian Schottenheimer.

          Like

          • adam

            Agree with you 10000000%.

            I hope Schotty gets cut loose. Tyson Helton at WKU would probably take the risk to come here next year. We could easily offer him 5x what he makes at WKU. He and Lincoln Riley were the finalists at OU last year. And since Riley probably isn’t leaving Oklahoma to come to Georgia after 1 year, Helton – who was also a finalist for the Georgia gig last year – would be a great hire. He also has experience as a ST coach.

            Like

          • Chickamona

            Succinct and excellent point. Even Bobo actually did incorporate a few things that worked in college like up-tempo and even some spread concepts. Schotty seems to have no interest or appetite for that and Richt brought him here.

            Tough watching Clemson (who has nearly always been a step behind us as a program) be #1 in the country with a QB from northeast Georgia, while we struggle to move the ball at all and will enter 2016 as a third straight year without a QB ready to play at a high level.

            Like

    • Will (the other one)

      That’s my take too. I even thought the lack of variety in run plays in the first 2 games was intentionally playing vanilla to better sneak up on SCar and Bama. But no, that’s the run game he calls.

      He now tops Cool Breeze in the pantheon of Worst Coordinator Hires going back to the Donnan years.

      Like

  6. Derek

    They did a bunch of 3 receiver alignments to one side. I even saw them go empty more than once. The problem with trying to take what they give you is that 2nd and 10 after an incompletion, 2nd and 16 after a sack or gsu ball after a pick is not better than 2nd and 7 after hammering it up the gut. The reason we suck on 3rd down is because we are terrible on 1st down. They played man all night and used their safeties in run support and we couldn’t do much about it. The 3rd and 4 on our chance to win in regulation just illustrates the problem. Good play call. Good route. Open receiver. Missed him. Flat missed him. That’s an easy throw.

    Like

    • GSU’s corners gave Georgia’s receivers all kinds of room, unless it was an obvious passing down. And when Georgia spread them out in four-receiver sets, the safeties couldn’t stay in run support. Sorry, but in my book, that’s doing something about it.

      Like

      • Derek

        And when they threw out if those sets how’d they do?

        Like

        • Better than when Lambert was under fire. And Michel runs better when he’s got space.

          I’m not arguing that Georgia was going to put up 500 yards and 50 points last night, Derek. But when your offensive line is being overwhelmed because the opponent is putting eight and nine in the box, don’t you think it makes sense to find a way to even the numbers? And when you do find a way, maybe stick with it, at least until they show you their defense can handle it?

          Like

          • Mayor

            Senator, you are dead right about this. Georgia’s very first possession of the game the O did some of what you are saying and it worked like a charm. Never went back to it except once in a while.

            Like

      • Derek

        My point is that they did try to help with alignments, but it’s not like the offense got better or more productive. I think by the end they were hoping they’d be worn out too if we kept running. Sony’s 25 yard scamper showed they were right in that. Had they thrown it 40 times to try and get those safeties back we’d probably have lost in regulation.

        Like

        • They didn’t have to throw it 40 times. You can – and they did – run effectively out of those 4-wide sets.

          Like

          • Derek

            Maybe we should have a film breakdown session and see whether the alignment differences helped. If it did I didn’t notice the correlation. What I saw even when we did spread out was that gsu would run blitz and stop the run or be right in lambert’s lap if it were a pass. They were shooting lbs in gaps and bringing pressure off the guy who was on the slot receiver. The real answer is a cool qb that checks off and makes them pay.

            Like

      • doofusdawg

        I saw several times when we ran the zone read out of these formations that if Lambert had kept the ball he would have run for a while. Schott should have told him to keep it on at least one occasion… take the decision out of his hands… that’s coaching.

        I did like the little side toss that we ran a couple times for a short yardage first down. Why in the world we waited till our second to last game to install it or call it is typical cmr. But we also ran zero toss sweeps . We did fun the little inside toss several times but once again not attacking the edge allowed gs to focus on the middle… which they did.

        At this point I will honestly be surprised if Eason is here in January.

        Like

    • Will (the other one)

      But by advanced stats we’re the opposite of terrible on 1st down (in fact, we’re 2nd best on first down, and 10th best on 2nd. Then all the way down to 103rd on 3rd down). http://www.footballstudyhall.com/pages/2015-georgia-advanced-statistical-profile

      Like

      • Dave

        Exactly. Derek, I like your passion, but I think you are off on this one. All year, I think lambert is better on 3rd and long than on 3rd and short. The Senator posted about it I think. Some stats probably aren’t backing up the argument you are making in this thread

        Like

        • Derek

          Lies, damn lies and statistics.

          The s&p+ rankings also say that we’re the second best third quarter offense in the country. You believe that and I’ve got some beachfront property in greater Harira.

          You could say that schotty is the second best oc at halftime in the country with those stats if you’d like, but from my vantage point we’ve pretty much sucked in every quarter.

          Like

  7. It’s Lamberts fault. It’s all Lamberts fault. Just like it’s the nails’ fault when the building comes falling down, not the carpenter who put it there.

    Like

    • Derek

      If you prefer you can blame Lambert for playing so well that you won’t get Coach X next fall.

      Chili and the rest of you: coaches don’t play man and 9 in the box and run blitz because of the other teams OC. They play man and 9 in the box because of the other teams qb. The OC can’t tell the other teams safeties to BACK THE FUCK UP!!! The only person on the field that can make them back off is the qb. If you have a better “football worthy” answer, go for it, but all I read is platitudes and complaining.

      Like

    • To be fair, some of it is Lambert’s fault. He missed a lot of reads last night.

      Like

      • Of course it is, but is it his fault that he’s the best we’ve got? He didn’t pick himself as the starter. He didn’t recruit himself from UVA.

        When you build a house with inferior materials, you don’t blame the materials, you blame the guy who built it.

        Like

        • Derek

          No one says it’s not CMR’s responsibility to have a decent qb out there. It is. The only question is does that failure mean axing him when Eason is on the way?

          Like

          • The problem isn’t just QB. These personnel issues exist across the board and Eason will not change that. I don’t care if Eason is on the way or not. If he wants to play for Georgia he’ll play for Georgia. If he only wants to play for Richt then he can go somewhere else as far as I’m concerned.

            Like

      • Derek

        And wide open guys. He threw and missed open guys. He threw to covered guys when others were open. He ate the ball and took sacks when receivers were open. I would not want to game plan or call plays right now. It seems insurmountable. I was panicking when we tried to move the ball with 47 seconds in the 4th. I just knew he was going to turn the ball over and they’d hit a chip shot and win. Sanford might have imploded if they take a knee there, but I probably would have done just that.

        Like

        • Lambert’s passer rating last night was his best since the Southern game. No, he wasn’t great, but he wasn’t an unmitigated dumpster fire, either.

          You’re making this all about Lambert, and that’s your opinion, so fine, but it’s Schottenheimer’s job to figure out a way to squeeze every drop of production he can out of a subpar unit. And he’s failed miserably at that this year. I don’t see how you can watch the offense play and deny that.

          Like

          • Derek

            I think they’re squeezing the hell out of it. I really do. I may be too tough on qbs but when I see a guy roll left and throw right into the middle of the field to nobody in the red zone, I’m done. Can’t have that. That is not a coaching issue. That is “I have no idea what the hell I am doing out here.”

            Like

          • Mayor

            Part of Lambert’s problem IMHO is the way the QBs have been handled this season. Pick one dammit! Then let him (and the team) know he is THE GUY. Give him all the the reps with the first team in practice. Don’t be standing around with the hook all the time. That crazy stunt Schotty (and I guess CMR, too) pulled over the 2 weeks leading up to the WLOCP with Bauta has to rank right up there with the stupidest coaching decisions in Georgia football history. If they decided to make Bauta the starter at least they should have modified the O to make better use of Bauta’s legs. Instead they ran the same offense with Bauta and he is the weakest passer of the three.

            Like

      • ClydeBoogie

        Like all night, he reminds me of a super nervous freshman. It’s hard to believe he was a starting quarterback anywhere. If Ramsey can’t supplant this guy, there is no need to transfer he will not get a better shot to play anywhere else. Richt has to work with Eason can’t chance it with Schotty. The entire offense is outta sync.

        Like

  8. I throw this out for what ever small amount it may be worth….on the Bulldawg brunch radio show both the idiot commentators are complaining that we didn’t run with a fullback in the backfield enough . Before people are allowed to express their opinions on the public air waves they should have to take and pass a test and being able to kick a football soccer style does not get you a pass (i.e. Kevin Butler) on being that oblivious to what was and was not working. Why is a five yard hitch pass to Godwin not considered as worthy and fulfilling as a 5 yard dive play. You are right Senator that failure to adapt on the fly is somewhat concerning. The spread formation gave us both a short passing game and clearly opened up the middle simultaneously.

    Like

    • Will (the other one)

      3- and 4WR and short passing game was the way to light them up. After the first drive, where Lambert looked great, and got a lot of passes on first down instead of 3rd & long, I thought Schotty had figured out that pounding the strong part of GASO’s d was a mistake, and picking on their undersized corners would work much better.
      Sadly it did not last.

      Like

  9. Grathams replacement

    I missed all the I formations, I saw 90% one back that let southern key on Sony without anyone to lead block the DL going thru the turnstiles.

    Like

  10. Timphd

    This offense is truly offensive. I haven’t seen an abomination quite like this in many many years, and I am an old Dawg. I watched that whole game wondering how on God’s earth this offense got so bad so fast.

    Like

  11. Rampdawg

    I have been a UGA fan since 1966, when I first listened to UGA radio, UGA vs. Ole Miss. In all these 49 yrs. of following and rooting on UGA. This is, without question, the most pathetically awful UGA offensive team I have ever seen. I don’t know if Richt stays or goes, but Shittenhiemer has got to go.

    Like

    • This is the conundrum though, isn’t it? There’s no question Schottenheimer isn’t working out. But who can Richt possibly get if he stays? Assuming Schottenheimer leaves and Richt gets another year, what decent OC in their right mind is going to hitch his wagon to a coach who everyone can tell ia treading dangerously thin ice?

      I don’t think you can let Richt make another OC hire. Either Richt and Schottenheimer both stay, or they both leave.

      Like

      • Russ

        I think if Richt stays and Schitty goes, Richt is going to have trouble getting a big OC hire in here. If he can’t, then I think he has to take an up and comer and groom him, while Richt handles a lot of the offense himself (like he did with Bobo early on).

        But Schitty has got to go.

        Like

      • Mayor

        I think the perception of CMR being on thin ice last year is at least part of the reason we ended up with Schotty. Likely nobody better would take the job with the prospect that CMR might be gone if the season went south. That also explains Schotty’s multi-year contract.

        Like

        • Will (the other one)

          Stanford’s Oline coach and WKU’s QB/OC were interested and by all accounts interviewed.
          Florida managed to snag Roper — who was certainly better than Schotty — coming off a 4-8 season.
          The “who can you get that’s better” argument works at the head coaching level, but as far as replacing Schotty? Not at all. The cheap promotion of Lilly to OC we worried about last year looks so, so, so much better than Schotty at this point.

          Like

          • adam

            Those guys interviewed. And so did Roper.

            Schotty must interview well to beat out all of those guys. I figured Lincoln Riley, with his success at ECU, was the obvious choice. But Tyson Helton or Kurt Roper or Mike Bloomgren are clearly all better options than Schotty.

            Honestly, it looks like Southern Cal isn’t going to keep Clay Helton. He is an excellent collegiate pro-style OC. He is from the South (born in Gainesville, FL, went to Auburn and transferred to Houston, coached at Memphis for a while). Since he will be unemployed, he would be a pretty good hire.

            Like

    • The Nelson Puppet

      You obviously have forgotten 1969, then. I encourage you to go to YouTube and watch the entire Georgia – Tennessee game. The 1969 offense makes 2015 look ultraproductive.

      Like

    • Gaskilldawg

      I remember 1973 and 1977. Both were bad years for our offense. Worse than this, even. Also 1984 was excruciating. 1989 offense struggled to score and 1990 was about as bad.

      Like

  12. Rampdawg

    Our offense reminds me of John McKay’s answer when asked about Tampa Bay’s offense during it’s 26 game losing streak. Reporter: “Coach, how do feel about your offense’s execution? McKay: “I’m all for it.”

    Like

  13. Lakatos Intolerant

    The misread on the deep out to the right sideline (trying to hit #5, I think) when #26 was in acres of space running the post was so demoralizing. Hard to tell which route was read #1 but Lambert should’ve seen the safety bite on the deep out, even had time to pump to sell it further, and launch it deep to #26. Would’ve been a score in any other year of the Richt era I’m convinced. Thankfully, Lambert sailed the throw out of bounds leaving no chance for a pick.

    Like

    • mg4life0331

      This. It doesn’t matter what you use to counter the box loading. Lambert will (*&#$ it up.

      Like

    • AusDawg85

      Its like he just refuses to go for that deep ball. Last year, Mason refused early to go deep in order to protect the ball. The coaches told him to “let’er rip” and he finally did take those deep shots to Conley, etc. They’ve said the same with Lambert, but he just won’t. You can see his receivers jogging back saying “WTF?!”

      Like

    • Clawing through the debris for any scrap of hope, I really like the way Godwin plays. When he gets a few more pounds on him and begins to deliver downfield blcoking he will be a super WR. Adjusting to LambertBall has already made him a better receiver, and it got us 6 points last nite.

      Like

  14. SouthGaDawg

    A win is a win. Living in South Ga and having degrees from both schools, I can honestly say that I hope this is the last game in this series. It’s always been a no-win situation for UGA. Wait…did I just contradict myself…

    Like

  15. W Cobb Dawg

    The malpractice dates to before the season ever started. By not selecting a #1 QB until the last minute, we damaged ourselves by not getting the #1 sufficient reps with the first team. Schotty doesn’t know what he’s doing. And frankly, CMR isn’t looking very smart either.

    Like

  16. Fetch

    If we buy him a new crayon, can we get Bobo back?

    Like