Daily Archives: December 13, 2023

If you think things were already crazy…

you ain’t seen nothing yet.

College athletes who were denied the chance to play immediately after transferring a second time can return to competition, for now, after a federal judge issued a 14-day temporary restraining order Wednesday against the NCAA.

U.S. District Judge John Preston Bailey in northern West Virginia issued the order against the NCAA from enforcing the transfer rule. A lawsuit filed by West Virginia and six other states alleged the rule’s waiver process violated federal antitrust law.

A hearing on the restraining order is scheduled for Dec. 27, Bailey said.

The NCAA didn’t immediately indicate whether it would appeal the ruling.

But the NCAA did issue a statement:

Like so many other things now affecting college athletics, this could have been avoided by being proactive about not violating antitrust law… oh, wait.  Mark Emmert.  Never mind.

***********************************************************************

UPDATE:

54 Comments

Filed under See You In Court, The NCAA

An early look at the new direction

Just a reminder that we’ll be entering a new world next season…

That’s probably a 3:30 game if we’re still in the SEC on CBS world.

Announcing that on Good Morning America is an interesting touch.

61 Comments

Filed under Alabama, ESPN Is The Devil, Georgia Football

This offseason’s most important player?

Matt Hayes argues it’s none other than Carson Beck, who, according to Hayes, is much closer to being seen as an elite prospect for the NFL draft than we might expect.

Finally, there’s Beck, who 2 NFL scouts told SDS has a Day 1 grade for the 2024 NFL Draft, and could move as high as top 10 overall. If he leaves for the NFL and Raiola signs with Nebraska, Georgia’s quarterback room is suddenly in disarray.

Georgia also has redshirt freshman Gunner Stockton on scholarship, and has a commitment in the 2024 class from 4-star Ryan Puglisi.

“Once (Beck) gets to the Combine, once he throws at Georgia’s Pro Day, once he interviews face to face, he’ll knock it out the park,” an NFL scout told SDS. “He already has elite arm talent and good tape. Once he gets on a grease board and you can see his elite knowledge of the game, forget it. He’ll be the 3rd (quarterback) taken.”

Georgia, 2 different sources told SDS, has been working on a 2024 NIL compensation package for Beck since late October.

That last sentence isn’t in doubt, but the scope of the proposal is a different story.

Beck’s NIL compensation package more than likely needs to be at least the same amount (or more than) he’d earn for an annual salary in his 1st year in the NFL — not the the entirety of the rookie contract he signs.

In other words, last year’s No. 10 overall pick (Bears OT Darnell Wright) signed a deal worth $20.9 million — with a 1st-year salary cap number of $3.8 million.

“Needs” is in the eye of the beholder, of course, but nearly $4 million is some real money you’re talking about there.  (It’s times like these when I can’t help but wonder what Greg McGarity’s reaction would be to that kind of number, which is what he laid out for Richt’s last contract.  But I digress.)

As if that’s not enough, Hayes goes on to note that the entire portal market for quarterbacks is on hold, waiting to see what Beck does.

One SEC coach told SDS he believes the reason there are still no firm commitments from many top quarterbacks in the portal is because everyone is waiting on Beck’s decision. But how much longer will they wait?

That means quarterbacks Will Rogers (Mississippi State), Cameron Ward (Washington State) and Dante Moore (UCLA) — elite-level players who have been in the winter transfer portal since the day it opened Dec. 4 and haven’t committed — are on hold and still available. For now.

But the longer Beck takes to make a decision, the more likelihood that 1 or a majority (or all) of the top quarterbacks available commit to other programs to avoid a mad scramble to find a home for 2024. Hence, Smart’s need for a decision from Beck.

Another SEC coach told SDS he believes if Beck leaves, other quarterbacks would then consider entering the portal for the Georgia job.

“I think you can guess what quarterback I’m talking about,” he said.

That would be Texas quarterback Arch Manning, the No. 1 overall recruit in the 2023 class who chose Texas over Georgia but is currently 3rd on the depth chart behind starter Quinn Ewers (who said in November he’s returning to Texas in 2024), and backup Maalik Murphy.

Crazy stuff, man.

49 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football

Keeping it fresh

Interesting list here:

You’d expect a team appearing on that list to be in a rebuilding mode, but there sit Georgia and Alabama.  When Nick and Kirby tell a recruit if they’re good enough to play, they’ll play, they aren’t bullshitting.

10 Comments

Filed under Alabama, Georgia Football

Skipping out on the check

When last we left the smoldering husk of the Pac-12, Oregon State and Washington State, the only two schools left standing, were put in a position to control the conference’s direction as its remaining members scattered for the greener pastures of the Big 12 and Big Ten.  So, in one sense, it’s easy to characterize this move as one born out of spite.

The legal fight over control of the Pac-12 took another turn last week when Oregon State and Washington State blocked a traditional multi-million-dollar revenue distribution from the conference office to the campuses, the Hotline has learned.

OSU and WSU called their decision “responsible” and suggested any other action would not be in the best interest of the future of the conference.

In response, the 10 outgoing members accused OSU and WSU of “abusing their position” — as allowed by a court order — and therefore causing harm to athletes at the outbound schools. The move “has nothing to do with the future of the Conference,” the 10 said in a joint statement.

The distribution is more of a tradition than a formal requirement under the conference’s bylaws, but when you dig down, there’s something more than spite going on here.

In response to a query from the Hotline about their decision to block the mid-year distribution, OSU and WSU issued a joint statement:

“As the only two remaining members, OSU and WSU are the only schools committed to the best interest of the Pac-12. That means taking responsible steps to protect the assets of the Conference and plan for the future.

“No member acting in the Pac-12’s best interest would allow departing schools to drain the Conference’s assets on their way out the door, while they refuse to pay their fair share of the liabilities.”

There are numerous liabilities, but one cast a larger shadow than all the others: an antitrust lawsuit against the NCAA and the Power Five conference filed by former Arizona State swimmer Grant House on behalf of thousands of former athletes.

The lawsuit seeks 1) backpay for name, image and likeness opportunities and 2) a 10 percent share of the massive media rights deals between TV networks and the conferences.

The case was recently elevated to class status, meaning the damages could climb into the billions.

A trial is set for January 2025 — after the Pac-12’s departing schools have left the conference.

“The departing schools have not committed to a plan for addressing the liabilities,” a source said. “If there’s a judgment (in the House case), the named entities would be responsible. And the Pac-12 is a named defendant.”

Yeah, that would kind of suck getting left to hold that bag.  Although you have to admire the defense the departing ten have come up with:

“A decision to distribute 15 percent of the more than $400 million in net revenues to the members now to support student athletes, as the Conference has always done in December, has nothing to do with the future of the Conference. Instead, OSU and WSU’s refusal to agree to it shows that the two schools are abusing their position to injure our programs and athletes in violation of all prior precedents.…”

Do it for the kids, an evergreen proposition.

6 Comments

Filed under It's Just Bidness, Pac-12 Football

Serious as a heart attack

Nothing exudes gravitas like starting out an important legal announcement with “I’m a lifelong Gator”.

This is so dumb, she’s even managed to make Bill Hancock sound like a reasonable man.

Afterward, College Football Playoff executive director Bill Hancock issued a statement that read: “We will carefully review this demand for information, but it sure seems to be an overly aggressive reaction to a college football ranking in which some fans somewhere were bound to be disappointed.”

44 Comments

Filed under BCS/Playoffs, Political Wankery

The consequences of success

Josh Pate offers some words of support for those currently fretting over Georgia’s roster situation.

In short, if you’re one of those folks, you’re suffering from the elite college football version of first world problems.  Deep breaths, peeps.

13 Comments

Filed under Georgia Football