Kirby ‘splains it.
Kirby Smart said Georgia athletic director Greg McGarity was very receptive to his belief about player transfer releases. Smart said “about 80 percent” of players he has seen transfer later regret it, especially those who leave early in their careers. He has less issue with older players like A.J. Turman making a move.
Claiming that you’re doing it for the kids makes everything better. No doubt that’s a highly scientific study. I guess since Catalina’s a graduate transfer, Kirby assumes he has no regrets changing schools. What a lucky coincidence for both.
Keep in mind, though, that no matter what a player’s age may be, some aspects of transfer culture are immutable.
“Every situation is different,” Smart said. “But I don’t believe that you should allow guys to go within the conference, and I don’t believe it should be somebody on your schedule. That’s just my belief, and that’s what pretty much what every coach that I talked to believed.”
If he had just started with that and stuck with it, I wouldn’t have a problem with what’s happened (other than my general dislike for the NCAA’s transfer rules, of course). It’s the back-and-forth bullshit, the hardline stance combined with haggling, along with the flat-out dissembling about what Turman went through, that’s distressing. Evidently Smart didn’t absorb as much from Saban as I thought he had, particularly when it comes to something that was bound to happen with the coaching transition. How could he not be better prepared to deal with this?
Sure, he can learn and I hope that’s the case. But who’s gonna show him? Greg McGarity? As I said to someone yesterday, it’s astounding to me that an athletic department that boasts having someone as well-regarded as Claude Felton can manage to step in it as constantly on the PR front as Georgia’s does.