The Pirate has a fix he’d like you to know about.

Mike Leach’s “ambitious plan” to solve the player compensation issue in college football has so many holes in it — antitrust, academic, roster management — that it’s never going to be taken seriously.

Leach believes players should have a choice when entering college: You either join as an (1) amateur or you join as a (2) professional.

“With professionals comes responsibility,” he says. “Yeah, you will potentially make more money. But you are drafted and can be traded. That’s what professionals do. This college football group [of administrators], they are all shocked by that. Why are you shocked by it? Name one league of professionals who don’t do it that way.”

How many leagues of professionals have amateur players?  Eh, Leach is a coach.  And football coaches are always going to let their control freak flag fly, so I get where he’s coming from with this:

Under Leach’s plan, amateurs follow similar rules currently applied to college athletes. They are unpaid and they can freely transfer. However, amateurs would receive a $100,000 bonus once they graduate from the school with which they originally signed. If you transfer, Leach says, you’d give up the right to earn the bonus.

Those choosing to be professionals would be paid a salary from the school, sign a binding contract, and could be traded and cut from the team. They still must attend school. School salary pools are structured similar to the NFL, where franchises are limited in their spending.

Like I said, this is DOA.  There’s no collective bargaining agreement with the players.  And there’s no antitrust exemption.  Speaking of which, Leach does get this part right:

“They can’t even solve their own problems,” Leach says of Congress. “They don’t know the first thing about football, and we’re going to defer to a bunch of people who don’t know what they’re doing? What is the time frame? I don’t think they get it accomplished, but in the event they do, we’ll all be dead.”

Yar!

26 Comments

Filed under Mike Leach. Yar!

26 responses to “The Pirate has a fix he’d like you to know about.

  1. Can professionals be locked in a storage shed?

    Liked by 4 people

  2. sundiatagaines

    I can’t see how any of this becomes reality, but he’s sorta onto something with separating the kids into two buckets.

    1) I want to play football and get a college degree. (Nakobe Dean)

    2) I want to play football and don’t care if I get a college degree. (Cardale Jones)

    It keeps getting more untenable to have the exact same rules, schedules, academic plans, etc for both buckets.

    Like

  3. barneydawg

    “They” have already deferred to a bunch of people that don’t know what they are doing…..the NCAA.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. gurkhadawg

    Wouldn’t most of the problems with Leach’s plan be solved by the professional bucket players forming a union and negotiating a collective bargaining agreement?

    Liked by 1 person

  5. thelifeofthemind

    As you note, this is all a ploy to shift the balance of power even more in the coach’s favor. Leach is just scared, and I get that. He wants that control. But this kind of progress for the players isn’t stopping anytime soon, regardless of how qualified he or anyone else thinks Congress is on the subject.

    Like

    • Agree, life, but the situation now is completely out of (anyone’s) control. It certainly hurts world class recruiters like Kirby and Nick when asshats like Jimbo can just buy a team. Of course, Kirby and Nick can too.

      Like

  6. uga97

    […But you are drafted.. ]

    How in the world does Leach envision that process to look like at the collegiate level?
    Yep. DOA

    Liked by 1 person

  7. jcdawg83

    I still think the only real solution is to completely scrap the current system and move more towards the D3 model. Make players have to be admitted to the school through regular admission channels BEFORE they can be on the football team. Let athletes be the same as regular students as far as transfers, meaning whenever and as many times as they want. NIL will work exactly the same as it does for any other student, if someone wants to pay a player for endorsing a product or an autograph, that is between the player and the person or business wanting the deal. Athletes can pay their tuition with money earned through NIL deals or they can pay like all the other students at the college.

    This would force the NFL to create some sort of farm system. Colleges and their athletic programs do not exist to be an NFL minor league. Let the athletes who view attending college classes as a necessary evil required to audition for a job in the NFL have a path to the NFL like the farm system of MLB. The athletes who want a college degree but want to play a sport can do so.

    The quality of play would go down as would the tv money, coaches salaries, facilities race and all the insane spending related to college football we have today. Fans who crave the higher level of play could go to or watch the new NFL farm teams play. The fans who want to watch a college team play would continue to attend the college games. As long as the teams were on equal footing the play would be competitive and entertaining.

    Liked by 3 people

  8. “Here’s a little some to help your Momma” envelope under the table is now “I’ve arranged a $5000/month endorsement deal for you” and the coaches are offended to have to do this. Admittedly, it takes more work now and distracts from locking down their own buyout clauses.

    Any proposal to limit SA earning potential needs to also cap coaching and AD compensation (which non-profits somewhat face already in the form of penalty taxes for comp over $1M). Impose a 75% personal income tax on these guys for comp over $1M and watch heads explode. Stop trying to prevent NIL and work towards a system that is better, safer, more transparent and grows opportunities…the stuff the suits can control.

    Like

    • Any proposal to limit SA earning potential needs to also cap coaching and AD compensation (which non-profits somewhat face already in the form of penalty taxes for comp over $1M). Impose a 75% personal income tax on these guys for comp over $1M and watch heads explode.

      College sports tried a cap once and lost an antitrust case over it.

      As for the second, I can’t think of a stronger way to guarantee Republican opposition than to call for raising taxes on someone.

      Like

      • First, I’m not an advocate of either. Just think the coaches should quite whining and work towards reform that helps, not restricts. Secondly, the current NPO excise tax is on the institution which had full Republican support. And R’s on the tax committee continue to be in love with targeted taxes in obscure areas to pay for broader tax cuts elsewhere.

        My last comment stands…reform should come from within that helps SA with deals, are legally sound, transparent and protected. Hell…might as well appoint Jimmy Sexton as czar of NIL. If one is offended that a player would choose a school where they can earn more in NIL, then you must also be offended that a pre-law student chooses Harvard over Georgia State.

        Like

    • rigger92

      That 75% tax is penalizing the wrong party, it’s not the coaches’ fault that athletic associations are willing to spend a fortune on a coach.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. godawgs1701

    This isn’t the first time that I’ve thought Mike Leach might not be as smart in the rest of life as he is when coaching offensive football.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. W Cobb Dawg

    “…we’re going to defer to a bunch of people who don’t know what they’re doing?”

    I agree. Since a large segment of coaches are losers (and don’t know what they’re doing, how bout we take half the coaches pay and distribute it to the players? Also stop collecting athletic fees from the student body.

    Like

  11. Russ

    Leach talks a lot and many times it’s entertaining. But here’s something he’s never said:

    “No comment”.

    Liked by 2 people

  12. mg4life0331

    Well he’s not wrong. Government sucks at resolving issues.

    Like

  13. theotherdoug

    I like the idea of a graduation bonus.

    Like

  14. Harold Miller

    All this talk about unions gets me to thinking about Billy Bragg.

    Like